3 ms·
Hmm I read it as "if you read/are being read to more, you're doing better at reading". Am I wrong? I do think the younger generation is shooting themselves in
by nottorp 7y ago
Hmm I read it as "if you read/are being read to more, you're doing better at reading". Am I wrong?
I do think the younger generation is shooting themselves in the foot with not being able to assimilate information by reading any more (video tutorials take 10x the time to convey the same amount of information if you can actually read efficiently), but this study seems to basically say that you're not proficient at a skill you don't practice?
- erikbye 7y ago> (video tutorials take 10x the time to convey the same amount of information if you can actually read efficiently Many subjects are better suited to video and can be conveyed more efficiently so. Especially complex UIs, in my experience. Learning to use and find my way around Maya was way easier and quicker using video than text with images. I definitely feel the same way about learning to do specific car repairs/maintenance.
- nottorp 7y agoRight, but some young uns need video tutorials to write code... not to work in a visual medium like Maya.
- the_af 7y agoAgreed. I never understood the videos for programming language courses at, say, Coursera. Written material is better and clearer. The slow speed of the videos drives me mad. Instead of digesting the information and examples at your own pace, you must watch as the teacher carefully enunciates his words and takes forever to belabor a point you already understood. But strangely enough, some people prefer video to actually reading a detailed, step-by-step written tutorial. Go figure.
- chadlavi 7y agoThis has absolutely nothing to do with children under five.
- erikbye 7y agoWhat is the point of your comment? Not every comment to an article will pertain directly.
- cowsandmilk 7y ago> Am I wrong? They didn’t just measure being able to read. They also focused on verbal ability using the EVT-2 and CTOPP-2 Rapid Object Naming tests. From what I can find, neither of those tests involve reading. According to its documentation, “The EVT–2 measures expressive vocabulary and word retrieval of the spoken word in standard American English and thus assesses vocabulary acquisition.” The details of the CTOPP-2 Rapid Object Naming test are harder to find, but it is a part of the test that is considered to not rely on reading. From the docs “ Rapid Non-Symbolic Naming Composite Score (RNNCS) comprises the standard scores of two subtests-Rapid Color Naming and Rapid Object Naming and offers an alternative for young children, ages 4 through 6 year olds, not familiar with letters and numbers. The RNNCS measures the examinee's ability to include efficient retrieval of phonological information from long-term or permanent memory and executing a sequence of operations quickly and repeatedly using objects and colors.“ [0] https://images.pearsonclinical.com/images/Products/EVT-II/evt2.pdf https://images.pearsonclinical.com/images/Products/EVT-II/ev... [1] https://www.proedinc.com/Products/13080/ctopp2-comprehensive-test-of-phonological-processingsecond-edition.aspx https://www.proedinc.com/Products/13080/ctopp2-comprehensive...
- Igelau 7y ago> the younger generation is shooting themselves in the foot with not being able to assimilate information by reading any more The old myth that successive generations bring themselves up by their own bootstraps. I'll never understand how this nonsense persists.
- nottorp 7y agoHmm and in English?