2 ms·
I wonder if the EU has done any other notable things to fight mass surveillance, because if so it would mean they weren't focusing on one particular identificat
by bryanrasmussen 7y ago
I wonder if the EU has done any other notable things to fight mass surveillance, because if so it would mean they weren't focusing on one particular identification method. I mean maybe they are working on multiple fronts.
Also perfect being the enemy of the well-intentioned here.
- igorkraw 7y agoWell the GDPR helped quite a bit already. Creates a proper inventive to not "just for good measure" aggregate PI
- kuschku 7y agoEspecially if one considers how the NSA got most of their data through PRISM from corporate partners like Google. If those never collect it, the NSA can't gather it.
- martin_a 7y agoGeneral data retention was also banned by EU courts, I think. While Germany is over and over trying to integrate something like that with dubious reasoning ("it will only be used against terrorists and other really bad crimes" - reality is that everybody wants his piece of it, even to use against false parking), the EU regularly puts a stop to this. So, it's great to have this higher-level legislative to stop single countries efforts, but there could even be done more...
- bryanrasmussen 7y agoyes, I suppose my post was too dryly sarcastic to be obvious but really the EU has been doing quite a bit more than other nations or international organizations to stop the surveillance state and it seems a little unfair to pick on what attack of a symptom and saying but stopping this symptom won't do enough. Not sure if this kind of problem isn't best solved by attacking the symptoms anyway, until you build up a sort of selection of anti-surveillance principles that can be used to decide new laws and regulations. But I guess I'm pretty pro-EU so this kind of thing makes me grumpy.
- martin_a 7y agoMissed half your point. ;-) Nevertheless, I think temporary bans are not a bad idea till we can come up with a better solution. Let's see what others are making out of this for the next five years, and come up with better rules. I'm totally with you on that.