4 ms·
How long before we see an article about consumers repairing and chasing down ancient refrigerators that are sadly inefficient but at least repairable? Ineffici
by userbinator 7y ago
How long before we see an article about consumers repairing and chasing down ancient refrigerators that are sadly inefficient but at least repairable?
Inefficient? Maybe "old" (60s-80s?), but not "ancient" (30s-50s) --- this article might be worth reading:
http://web.archive.org/web/20121218033749/http://www.greenbuildingadvisor.com/blogs/dept/musings/choosing-energy-efficient-refrigerator http://web.archive.org/web/20121218033749/http://www.greenbu...
The 1930s GE Monitor-Top (ironicallly also made by GE, but the good old GE) uses less power than a lot of modern refrigerators, and many others from that era are similar. Despite their age, used working ones are very expensive.
I have a 1938 Frigidaire which I restored. The compressor, which was marketed as the "Meter-Miser", draws less than 100W when running, and it doesn't run very often. So far it seems it will be around 280kWh/year. It has no "smarts" to subvert me, and the sealed nature of the system means that it could likely continue running for another century and outlast me...
- gdm85 7y agoGreat article! Thanks for the link. Nowadays I cringe when I regularly see small fridges completely encased in furniture in hotel rooms, with no air circulation. They get very warm and even the top surface of the furniture sometimes. I wonder what William Holladay, the grandfather of the article's author, would have to say about that. The idea of putting the compressor on top is also interesting, why is it not being pursued? Noise issues?
- hvidgaard 7y agoA modern fridge use less than half of that, that will probably not be anything that matters. In Denmark with the current power prices, that'll pay for a new fridge over 10 years. That isn't exactly a good case for buying a new one.
- mosselman 7y agoI am more interested in the effect on the environment. What is the break even point for replacing an inefficient fridge with a new one in terms of damage to the environment considering things like the production process, transport and the eventual power consumption?
- hvidgaard 7y agoIf that is the meter stick, then replacing the compressor with a better one is probably the best course of action.
- floatingatoll 7y agoOne site suggests that a refrigerator has 5900 megajoules of energy embodied in it. That's accurate enough for napkin math, so we'll run with it. 1 kWh = 3.6 megajoules, so 1638 kWh per refrigerator. https://energyeducation.ca/encyclopedia/Appliance#Embodied_energy https://energyeducation.ca/encyclopedia/Appliance#Embodied_e... Two hops upthread, the commenter says "280kWh/year" for their 1938 fridge. No clue what kind of power they use, but we can calculate the recoup cost of a replacement without knowing it. It looks like modern refrigerators are considered about 3x as efficient as pre-70s refrigerators, so let's say that a straight swap of a size-equivalent refrigerator of average efficiency will cost 100kWh/year. https://www.energystar.gov/index.cfm?fuseaction=refrig.calculator https://www.energystar.gov/index.cfm?fuseaction=refrig.calcu... Spending 1638 kWh on a new refrigerator will save 160kWh/year, so the break even point in carbon terms occurs after 10 years have passed. This is all very bad napkin math done in crayon. If you want better figures, you'll need to know your own refrigerator runtime figures, which means measuring your fridge's power usage for a standard week of use (if you maintain a very stable indoor temperature through heating/cooling) or for a year (if you do not), and you'll need to know the energy saved per year of your current fridge, and etc. ps. Apparently they have a fridge from 90 years ago that's still running. If you replace one modern fridge with another and only save 20 kWh/year, it will take you 90 years to recoup that cost. The 10 year figure is only possible because their 1938 fridge is so inefficient. pps. Owner of said 1938 fridge, I intend no disrespect. This DOE paper talks in detail about the changes that improved efficiency – inventing high-efficiency compressors, changing the shape of the drain pipe (1% efficiency gain!), and replacing the refrigerant and insulation materials with more efficient ones. https://www.nrel.gov/docs/legosti/old/7281.pdf https://www.nrel.gov/docs/legosti/old/7281.pdf
- userbinator 7y agoIt looks like modern refrigerators are considered about 3x as efficient as pre-70s refrigerators, so let's say that a straight swap of a size-equivalent refrigerator of average efficiency will cost 100kWh/year. ...and that's where you're wrong. These are the most efficient as of 2020: https://www.energystar.gov/most-efficient/me-certified-refrigerators https://www.energystar.gov/most-efficient/me-certified-refri... The top of that list is a 5.1cft model that uses 186kWh/year. The next one is also roughly the same size and uses 202kWh/year, followed by an 8.8cft that uses 294kWh/year. 100kWh/year is, frankly speaking, impossible. Mine has 9cft. That "calculator" is being very deceptive by grouping everything "before 1980" together. The 60s and 70s models are certainly far more power-hungry because they made them bigger and with thinner insulation (more interior space) and things like defrost heaters, but the ones before that are not. This DOE paper talks in detail about the changes that improved efficiency ...and none of the energy usage figures they quote are anywhere near the 300kWh/year range. A look at the real numbers shows just how efficient these early models are.