4 ms·
It's crazy to me just how different voices and the accent were back then. So many women had this very high-pitched and constricted, and almost childlike "shril
by crazygringo 7y ago
It's crazy to me just how different voices and the accent were back then.
So many women had this very high-pitched and constricted, and almost childlike "shrill" voice.
While men had vowels that were so wide-open laterally, but lacking in upper overtones (the opposite of nasality).
And I don't think you can ascribe any of it to the recording technology -- even if you record someone today and cut off higher/lower frequencies, they don't sound anything like that.
- shmerl 7y agoThat's very interesting indeed. Was it a kind of dialect that developed that way? I remember, first Bioshock game tried to capture such pronunciation.
- joegahona 7y agoIt's interesting for me too. I wonder if vocal fry existed back then, or if that's something people will point out as a period thing 100 years from now.
- foldingmoney 7y agoPeople point that out as annoying now.
- crocodiletears 7y agoAnnoying as it may be, it doesn't have to be pleasant to or even popular with broader society in order to be something iconic to our era. I can't speak to whether that's the case, though.
- midgetjones 7y agoI think that's more a result of recording technology improvements, so it wouldn't have been practical or possible in those days.
- wayoutthere 7y agoI suspect more people back then were trained from a young age as singers (even if informally). That would reinforce habits of using various parts of their voice; a soprano voice does sound lovely when used for singing but can be a bit nasal when used for speaking. Likewise, a bass would have been trained to keep his voice within a certain range that keeps the resonance in his chest, which can lead to a "flat" sounding voice when used for speech. The accents and vocal qualities didn't really start to homogenize across the country until the 1920s when radio became widely commercialized, and likely didn't become common until the kids from that generation were adults.
- chrisco255 7y agoI think the homogenization came with interstates, jets, and the quicker movement of people around the country. Your accent tends to come from the peers you were exposed to as a child and teenager and is nearly fixed by the time you're an adult. I have noticed a generational decline in southern accents in my own family. But my grandfather was born well after the radio became widespread.
- NeedMoreTea 7y agoThe fascinating thing is the same applied for female voices in the same era in the UK too. I had always thought it was some artefact of the awful posh received pronunciation everyone was expected to adopt going through school. If you listen to pre-war newsreels or movies you'll get the same shrill female tones. Hearing Australian from then is similar, though sounds much like UK RP, with a more gentle hint of "Strine" than you'd expect today. Yet anyone who's been around long enough will have probably dropped pitch over the years. Listen to any wartime or pre war famous women speaking and hear them twenty or thirty years later, e.g. the Queen, Vera Lynn, not only has the stuck up constricted accent gone, but the pitch has dropped markedly too.