6 ms·
This is an interesting post if you also follow the subreddit for Yang[0]. There are a lot of people there that created Twitter accounts just to follow Yang and
by godelski 7y ago
This is an interesting post if you also follow the subreddit for Yang[0].
There are a lot of people there that created Twitter accounts just to follow Yang and participate in those polls about who is more popular. So when the author mentions the creation of new accounts when Yang started, it actually doesn't surprise me. The campaign is very technocentric after all. Also, these people (a lot of them "true believers" types) do post A LOT on Twitter and get involved in any mention of Yang (go check any YouTube video about Yang). You have to "yang" everyone that you can. It is a really weird community to be honest. But one where they are actively telling one another to create social media accounts to promote Yang. What this post really tells me is that it is hard to distinguish real people from bots. Here's a post even about YouTube comments[1].
[0] https://www.reddit.com/r/YangForPresidentHQ/ https://www.reddit.com/r/YangForPresidentHQ/
[1] https://www.reddit.com/r/YangForPresidentHQ/comments/esycun/the_daily_show_reposted_their_getting_to_know/ https://www.reddit.com/r/YangForPresidentHQ/comments/esycun/...
- ci5er 7y agoSeems (to me) to be similar to the Ron Paul bots (fanatics, I should say, because they certainly weren't mechanical war-bots; They seemed like what the right calls NPCs these days, but they were just so ... into it! 24/7! It's actually kind of nice to see groups of new/young people get excited about politics - I think they might learn a lot through the process (maybe)) all over Reddit in 2008 (not just /r/politics, but they were everywhere), esp. since that also included all of the influx of rapidly migrating Diggers. Maybe it's not the same, but those folks were all in on the Paul Train (or whatever they called it). They were eggcited!
- kevitivity 7y agoSo true, the "Paulestinians" as I called them were the first thing that came to my mind while reading this. There is too little detail of methodology in this article to take it too seriously, but still interesting.
- ci5er 7y ago> "Paulestinians" Ha! Never heard that one. It is by far more clever than any of the half-dozen or so that I did.
- charlesju 7y agoI'm curious why you think it's weird for a group of people to believe passionately about a candidate?
- godelski 7y agoI like Yang, but I've never been one that idolizes another person. I would 100% vote for Yang above another candidate (I'm actually even surprised HN, which is pretty pro UBI, isn't Yang Gang), but I've never been passionate about another person. I don't understand people that will move to another state to campaign for a candidate. I've never been part of that kind of movement before, and in it I don't understand it. So it is weird to me. I will describe people in Bernie's camp, Trump's, and others the same way. Fanatics confuse me in the same way. I do also have a religious past and it reminds me of the fanaticism of that as well. But we're all humans and see through different lenses. It just is a lens that is odd to me.
- charlesju 7y agoI understand that perspective, but I hope you can see that unlike a religion, politics, especially in USA is through people. People need to push a specific candidate because they represent a vision for yourself and the people you love. One key thought experiment I like to do is to project out a behavior pattern for all people and then asking whether that would be a positive or negative for yourself and society. If everyone were to campaign and push for the ideas they care about, I do believe that would result in a more informed and better society. Through the marketplace of ideas, we can fight through the differences and hopefully create better policy and have better leaders execute on our future. I think for a lot of people, taking action to affect change for the community/society you live in is very natural. On a small scale that can be something like running for class president or joining your HOA. At a larger scale, politics is where change happens. If you believe in a set of principles, it is sometimes worth your personal time, effort, and money to affect change. Hopefully you can see that from their perspective they are about their own future and this is the most effective way to impact that prospective future.
- 7y ago
- RyJones 7y agoI had no position on Yang. After a couple very negative experiences with the Yang Gang, where anything less than instant adulation must mean you're anti-Yang, I'm anti-Yang.
- ztratar 7y agoSorry you had a couple bad experiences with folks. I'm biased, but I think Yang's message is more positive than others. Hopefully over time he can earn back your trust.
- joejerryronnie 7y agoFunny, I had the same experience with Bernie.
- pstuart 7y agoAnd I had the same experience with Hillary, yet I still voted for her (not as enthusiastically as I'd have liked) because I don't want to let a bunch of jerks make my mind up for me.
- gremlinsinc 7y agoWell, w/ Hillary she herself was toxic/evil. Her people were icing on the cake. If nobody existed but a Yang Gang member and Bernie - could they really admit he wasn't authentic and wanted to make the world better? Is he corrupt? Is he in this for himself? To enrich his businesses per se? Sell more books? Has he changed his message to win? Or is he consistent? I mean look at the candidate. Sure the community can get toxic like a rivalry highscool football game with pranks and shit, but in the end. Are the players really evil, or do their fans just go way out of proportions and get way too overly excited and/or angry when things don't go their way?
- godelski 7y ago> Has he changed his message to win? Or is he consistent? Serious question, why is this a metric? Changing your mind should be a good thing. I find this odd coming from a tech and more science oriented website. I'm not saying that we should just encourage people to change on a whim but changing positions because 1) you're presented with new evidence and/or 2) the people you are representing have changed positions, this should be respected. There's a difference between changing positions and feigning belief. It is especially bad if you feign a position and work against that position (I can respect you if you even if disagree with a position but work for it because your constituents hold said belief). #1 is obvious why it is good (because we're human and fuck up). #2 is good because you're adapting to what those that you represent believe. I for one DO NOT want a president that is going to double down on bad beliefs and not change beliefs as either culture changes (e.g. Obama changed positions with gay marriage as the US culture changed) or because they are presented with new evidence. These things should be regarded as a good trait. tldr: why is consistency such a highly regarded metric?