8 ms·
Pharmaceutical Executive Sentenced To 66 Months In Prison In Opioid Trial
- planetzero 7y agoThis is a blow for anyone wanting to 'legalize all drugs'.
- theonemind 7y agoI don't think so, except inasmuch as confirmation bias will lead anyone with an anti-legalize-drugs bias to construe this as evidence for that position. The incentives for these actions can come in part from artificially high prices. More legalization gets you more players, and could perhaps dilute the power to use the machinery of doctors, drug companies, etc. as a top-down drug pushing force. Additionally, society tends to build up immunity with exposure. You can get more irrational behaviors with highly controlled or scarce things. In the short term, introducing a lot of free/legalized drugs into an already constrained society could increase damage, but for the long term? Not such a clear picture, in my opinion. Perhaps a slow loosing to allow society to adapt. Honestly, I see very little here to make this a blow against legalizing drugs besides confirmation bias for those already against it. It also leaves out the cost of the war on drugs, which you would, in a rational analysis, need to compare against the cost/problems of legalization, as the cost/problems of the war on drugs go down. Which one costs more? Organized crime takes a serious hit with legalization, a secondary benefit. Consider Prohibition in the United States. Alcohol's a drug, actually a fairly destructive one. Why did they repeal it?
- paulddraper 7y ago> The incentives for these actions can come in part from artificially high prices. The incentives for these actions come from any sort of price. Plus the addictive effect on the user.
- planetzero 7y ago"Honestly, I see very little here to make this a blow against legalizing drugs besides confirmation bias for those already against it." I don't see Budweiser execs going to prison for selling alcohol that resulted in someone become addicted or killing someone in an accident...which is most likely killing many more people per year than any other drug. "Organized crime takes a serious hit with legalization" This one has been proven false with MJ legalization. In California, for instance, legalization has only gotten more people interested in using and then when they realize they can get it for cheaper on the illegal market, it's put many legal shops out of business. With legalization comes higher prices (and possibly shortages and the inability to get it whenever you want). As a result, it has really done nothing to curb organized crime or illegal sales. This was only my theory before it was legalized, and now it has been proven correct. I guess drug users don't really care about paying their fair share. This was from a year ago, but things haven't changed much: https://www.latimes.com/politics/la-pol-ca-gavin-newsom-crackdown-pot-black-market-20190219-story.html https://www.latimes.com/politics/la-pol-ca-gavin-newsom-crac... "Consider Prohibition in the United States. Alcohol's a drug, actually a fairly destructive one. Why did they repeal it?" It only worked because they stamped out corruption and killed/jailed all of the organized criminals involved in the illegal booze business. With drugs, it's already gotten too big. The corruption in Mexico is at another level. The cartels run the country. The illegal market will never go away, especially since they don't have to deal with regulations and can provide a cheaper product (which will always be the case).
- thaumasiotes 7y ago> With legalization comes higher prices (and possibly shortages and the inability to get it whenever you want). This isn't actually a feature of legalizing trade in something. If you're just contrasting "legal drug sales" with "illegal drug sales", the illegal vendor has much, much higher costs and isn't in a position to charge lower prices. But California chose to impose ludicrously high compliance costs on the legal vendors, so high that illegal vendors can effortlessly beat them on price.
- planetzero 7y ago"The illegal vendor has much, much higher costs and isn't in a position to charge lower prices." I disagree. Illegal vendors don't have to follow labor laws (they can get much cheaper labor), regulations (they aren't limited by the rules imposed by their state/city), and taxation (they aren't paying extra taxes on top of their current costs). All of these equal lower prices. The legal market will almost never be able to complete with the illegal market, for these very reasons. "But California chose to impose ludicrously high compliance costs on the legal vendors," We were told that when MJ was legalized, all illegal vendors would go away and the state would see a boost in tax revenue. Where do you think this extra tax revenue comes from? Don't drug users want to pay their 'fair share' That I keep hearing about? The reality is they don't really care about paying any taxes and just want their drugs at the cheapest price. The current state of illegal sales clearly shows this.
- heavyset_go 7y agoThis company lied to prescribers and patients about their products' indications, efficacy and potential for harm.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- jimbob45 7y ago"The sales executive hired a stripper as a Subsys sales representative to help persuade doctors to boost prescriptions. The woman, named Sunrise Lee, eventually was promoted to oversee a third of the company's sales force." This is begging to be made into a movie.
- hinkley 7y agoExecutive Producers: Richard Gere and Julia Roberts
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- dvtrn 7y agoI’m gonna just go on a limb and guess that this was downvoted into the greys by people who never saw the movie “Pretty Woman” where this was very nearly the exact plot as the news story here and therefore completely missed the irony: It was a movie.
- blazespin 7y agoNot really. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pretty_Woman https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pretty_Woman I have to say, simply because the woman was a stripper does not preclude her from being an effective manager. Perhaps the article could have spent more time talking about dubious moral and unethical things that she did rather than her past history of removing her clothing. Profiling like this is only necessary when your life is potentially in danger, like being a cop in a dark alley. We're a modern society, can't we treat everyone as individuals to be respected?
- dvtrn 7y agoMay I kindly suggest a watch of the movie versus a read of an abridged plot from Wikipedia to see the associations I’ve drawn between this story and the movie? The parallels aren’t complete nor exhaustive but the way Gere’s character repeatedly parlays his relationship with Roberts for professional and social advantage (which is only one instance talked about in said wiki article) is one of the more prevalent themes in the film I and presumably the commenter I relied to are alluding to when connecting these dots of “art imitating life”. This isn’t an ethical argument about how effective sex-workers are in non-sex work careers but a critique of the power dynamics between two individuals. One who merely happened to be a sex-worker.
- vearwhershuh 7y agoIt's a start. Now do the Sacklers.
- ryan-allen 7y agoIs there any chance of that happening? This bloke is a "former billionaire", as opposed to a current one.
- elfexec 7y agoAlso this bloke was a "Kapoor". So he probably had very little political clout/connections and was simply targeted for convenience and used as a sacrificial lamb to placate the masses. The Sackler's are cash multibillionaires ( not stock billionaires ) and they have strong politicals connections in the NY area, etc. This case reminds me in some way of the Abacus trial. The only financial institution to be tried for the financial crisis was a small local bank founded by a "Sung". https://www.marketplace.org/2017/05/22/abacus-only-bank-charged-financial-crisis/ https://www.marketplace.org/2017/05/22/abacus-only-bank-char... You could watch a documentary about the case. https://www.pbs.org/wgbh/frontline/film/abacus/ https://www.pbs.org/wgbh/frontline/film/abacus/ The Kapoor case, like the Sung case, is really a show trial.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- chiefalchemist 7y agoFive years? All things considered? Lives ruined? Deaths? Etc.? Is a slap on the pinky finger. It'll be a country club prison. Sentence will be reduced for good behavior. Etc. Better than nothing I suppose. But not by much.
- roywiggins 7y agoThe minimum amount you can serve is 85% of the sentence, fwiw: https://prisonprofessors.com/rdap-truth-early-release-federal-prisoners/ https://prisonprofessors.com/rdap-truth-early-release-federa...
- threeseed 7y agoWell there's a very good chance he will die in prison.
- chiefalchemist 7y agoThat's hardly consolation for _all_ the lives wrecked?
- banads 7y agoIt's definitely disproportionate to what a street level dealer typically gets for pushing an extremely small fraction of opiods relative to what these people were doing.
- chiefalchemist 7y agoRight. He did the work of multiple dealers and got a fraction of the punishment. Evidently the criminal justice system has two problems. The victims and the loopholers.
- dpflan 7y agoTitle typo to fix: "eecutive" --> "executive"
- hinkley 7y agoHow many other people deserve to be right there with 'em? There's this whole other version of the rat race / climbing the ladder that is either new or I just didn't know about: If you can be adjacent to the people who can be blamed for something, you get to keep all the bonuses and not go to jail. Unless they find a way to blame the whole thing on you.
- heavyset_go 7y ago> How many other people deserve to be right there with 'em? Owners and board members certainly do. Despite their stature, executives are merely employees, and their job is to carry out the whims of the board and shareholders.
- cubano 7y agoYou have to think this is mostly a political show trial, with the main government players hoping to make a name for themselves for some future enrichments yet to be named. If as a side benefit, some execs think twice about pushing addictive pills to people who want them, I suppose that is a good thing as well, but to see this as much more then just a way for the prosecutor to "make hay" I feel misses the point.
- hinkley 7y agoAbsolutely. What galls me though is that in 30 years, when prosecuting things like this have long gone out of fashion, our grand kids will be having this very same conversation.
- untilHellbanned 7y agoGreat. Now do zuckerberg. Perhaps inarguably more mass destruction.
- etrk 7y ago> "Perhaps inarguably" Two words you rarely see together.
- paulddraper 7y ago> Perhaps inarguably HN can't decide if Facebook is irrelevant, or oppressive, but it's definitely one of those.
- maxfan8 7y agoThere is a typo in the title.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- Koshkin 7y agoWhy not the doctors?
- ceejayoz 7y agoThe DEA has gone after plenty, which has had significant chilling effect on the legit ones. Genuine chronic pain patients are in the middle and getting screwed.
- Consultant32452 7y agoIn the early 2000s my entire state was littered with "pain clinics" which were just fronts for medically licensed drug dealers. Those are all gone now.
- chooseaname 7y ago> "I didn't think of who we were at Insys and how unethical what we were doing was," he told the judge on Thursday, according to Bloomberg. "The only thing I could think was how could I keep up with the fast and furious pace necessary to get ahead." Sadly, I think people really do get caught up in the pace and don’t think about anything else. No excuse though.
- rjkennedy98 7y agoHow is being old a reason for a short sentence. Is being young an excuse for a longer sentence?
- a3n 7y agoIt's just one of many whiny tools in a lawyer's toolbox. The irony being that all those dead opioid users didn't have the chance to be old.
- madengr 7y agoHow in the hell did they charge $19k a month for fentanyl? The stuff is made on the industrial scale in China.
- WheelsAtLarge 7y ago20+ yrs ago Pharma was pushing doctors to use opioids more liberally since the manufactures said that they were safe for people that really needed it. Now we see that that was a mistake. I suspect that we are heading in the same direction with pot. In the future, we will be looking back and wonder why we were not careful with the use of it. I think it should be legal but it should not be treated like its use has no consequences.
- alphabettsy 7y agoIt’s not that something changed with opioids as a category, we’ve been using them forever. Drug companies made time release formulations of basically the same compounds and said they weren’t as addictive as the stuff we used before and that wasn’t true. In the US Doctors tend to do what the patient wants, which you would expect from a free-market healthcare system. This leads to patients often asking for medications, in addition to marketing reps incentivizing physicians who want to make their patients happy as quickly as possible. I don’t see a clear parallel.
- jMyles 7y agoOne of the main advantages of cannabis as medicine is that it is so forgiving when used in its therapeutic range. It is the inverse of opioid drugs in this respect: opioids are very powerful, but can fairly easily cause death or dependence when used even in the lower end of their therapeutic range. Cannabis is much less powerful of course, but can be titrated easily because it has so little acute toxicity even at huge doses.
- paulddraper 7y agoOne difference: it's impossible to die (immediately) from marijuana. Opiods? Yes. Asprin? Uh huh. Alcohol? Absolutely. Like tobacco, week can be harm you, but only over a long period of time.
- WheelsAtLarge 7y ago>One difference: it's impossible to die (immediately) from marijuana. You can overdose yourself with Cannabis Extracts. They are just as legal as the plant.
- Gatsky 7y agoGood. 5 years earlier would have saved lives. If only they could go back and haul up all the tobacco executives from nursing homes and golf courses and do the same.
- chkaloon 7y ago"U.S. District Judge Allison Burroughs explained that she reached the lesser sentence after considering Kapoor's advanced age and philanthropy" - So if you are going to hook people on your drugs, ruin their lives and make billions off of them, as long as you give some of it away that makes it better. Uh, ok.
- enjoyyourlife 7y ago"U.S. District Judge Allison Burroughs..." She's judged quite a few notable other rulings such as putting a hold on Trump's travel ban and the Harvard lawsuit