3 ms·
People seem to miss the point of Sonos. Yes, you can build a good stereo system, connect some kind of streaming system and end up with something roughly the eq
by nl 7y ago
People seem to miss the point of Sonos.
Yes, you can build a good stereo system, connect some kind of streaming system and end up with something roughly the equivalent of Sonos.
But this is the whole Dropbox vs Git+Remote Backup+Your own server thing.
The ease of use and "it just works" simplicity is the feature, and every other setup compromises this to some extent.
I have a Onkyo & Dali hi-fi setup. It's a great system. And I've made attempts to make it as easy to use as Sonos.
Let's go through the things I've tried and the compromises they have:
- Harmony remote + CEC to control the TV and stereo. This is ok (the Harmony products are good) but has *exactly the same issues as Sonos: a propriety system that is subject to upgrades. I've had to throw away one system already.
- Bluetooth streaming. Tried Airplay, but there is no reliable Android support. Bluetooth is ok, but if the range is annoying if someone is walking around the house.
- Zones. My amp sort of has a concept of this, but I haven't even attempted to get it to work. The wiring of speakers is enough to put me off it.
Sonos solves all these problems. But obsoleting their speakers is horrible, and 4 years seems too short a time for this.
I'm not sure what the solution is, but some kind of maintenance fee is something I'd consider - especially for older hardware. It'd have to be substantially less than what I pay for Spotify though. Maybe after 5 years I'd pay $10/year?
- cr0sh 7y agoWhat about something like this? http://strobe.audio/ http://strobe.audio/ I mean - that's just the first hit I found searching for open-source multi-room audio streaming for the raspberry pi. There were others. Seriously - once you got one node to work, at that point clone the sd card (just dd it), and pop the image onto new cards for each new node. I don't know what kind of configuration or fiddling you might have to do, and while it isn't a "plug-n-play" thing like Sonos, you (and everyone else here) probably have the smarts to figure it out. And once you have it figured out for one - the copying it and duping it to the other nodes and setting them up is probably not much of a stretch.
- nl 7y agoIt says on that site "the user interface is a work in progress". There a lots of these projects. They all sorts, kinda work if you are prepared to do work and ignore the faults. For one, it doesn't do HDMI CEC. For another, no form of surround sound. No Spotify support. Etc etc. I just don't think that trade-off is worthwhile. One you buy active speakers (which have to be wired to the raspberry pi, sigh..) it isn't even much cheaper.