4 ms·
> In general, I rely on lots of people. But for the most part, I choose who I rely on, and in some cases the set of people I rely on changes over time. I value
by vkou 7y ago
> In general, I rely on lots of people. But for the most part, I choose who I rely on, and in some cases the set of people I rely on changes over time. I value that choice and the freedom to change.
You don't have as many choices as you think, many of the choices that you do have are meaningless, and many of the choices you can make are only possible because of the particular level of wealth, power, and social standing that you currently have.
If I'm unhappy with the scummy behaviour of a credit rating agency, my only recourse is to cut off my nose to spite my face. (Opt out of credit entirely.)
If I'm unhappy with the scummy behaviour of my bank, I could switch to a competitor, which has the exact same policies, that bring about the exact same outcomes as the one I'm currently with.
I could move to a different city, and the players in this game will change, but the rules, and the outcomes, will remain the same.
Even when you have actual freedom to choose (Do you want to buy unorganic poor-person kale, or fully-woke, hand-raised, cruelty-and-gmo-free, organic kale?) - your choices are highly constrained by powers and circumstances you have absolutely no control over - and by your current personal level of wealth and status.
Someone with cash in the bank, in-demand skills, useful connections, and no debt hanging over their head has the choice to tell an unreasonable boss to back off. Someone without that level of wealth, power, and status doesn't have a meaningful choice in this regard. (And, ironically, are more frequently in a situation where they have to make that non-choice.)
- ixtli 7y agoFurther, there are 7.53 billion people on earth. If you conclude (generously) that, living in New York City, you have the freedom to associate and deeply rely on anyone in the tri-state area, you have access to about 20 million. That's 0.2% of the total addressable people, and living in NYC puts you near one of the largest population centers in the world. It would take large amounts of capital for you to switch to another fraction of a percentage of the total population, and in doing so you'd be abandoning much of that original 0.2%. You are far more constrained by your circumstances, by our social organization, and by physics than it might appear because of how easy it is to talk casually with others. Some of this we can overcome with changes to our society and development of technology, but some we probably can't. Your freedom to change your conditions falls off in power really quickly. Or, put another way, addressing the full set of choices gets expensive very quickly. EDIT: I liked doing this math and, having lived in Tokyo as well as NYC, you could increase that 0.2% to about 0.5% by moving to the center of Shibuya; about 40m people live in and around the administrative unit. It's the densest area of its kind on the planet. That said, measuring Tokyo is a bit of a fraught problem because there are multiple ways to outline the city itself.
- celticmusic 7y agoWhat's your point? That your one true love may be in nigeria, but you'll never meet them because you're in NY? I don't really understand why people make these kinds of posts as if it's some sort of wisdom. Everyone else innately understands that you can only interact with the people available for interactions to you, and that tends to be limited by locale. In fact, everyone understands it so well that most don't feel it needs to be said. But it doesn't change the point that you still can choose to move to nigeria if you want to interact with more nigerians, and that you can refuse to interact with that 1 asshole down the street even if you haven't met every person who ever existed during your lifetime.
- ixtli 7y agoThe top-most comment said > I value that choice and the freedom to change. and my point was that not only is this freedom curtailed by capital and circumstance, deploying capital to modify circumstance requires a shitload of it. Far beyond what is implied when people bandy about the slogan of "i'm free to associate with whomever i want." In reality, you're not! You're constrained six ways from sunday and the size of the constrained set is a fraction of a fraction of the total set of choices. I guess you can argue that this is totally intuitive to everyone and so my comment is obtuse but judging by the way people talk and behave it doesn't seem that way to me.
- celticmusic 7y ago> and my point was that not only is this freedom curtailed by capital and circumstance, deploying capital to modify circumstance requires a shitload of it. Far beyond what is implied when people bandy about the slogan of "i'm free to associate with whomever i want." I'm just going to quote myself. _But it doesn't change the point that you still can choose to move to nigeria_ This is like the people who argue that you shouldn't put in a solution that only makes the problem 20% better, that we should wait until it's a 100% solution. You should probably just curl up in your basement and wait to die since you apparently can't interact with everyone in the world.
- vorpalhex 7y ago> If I'm unhappy with the scummy behaviour of a credit rating agency, my only recourse is to... Opt out of credit entirely Well you have more options than that. You can freeze your credit reports, put holds on your information, and push your political representatives to engage with the issue. No, you can't single-handedly fix the problem, but it is a correctable problem. > If I'm unhappy with the scummy behaviour of my bank, I could switch to a competitor, which has the exact same policies You can also switch to a credit union which probably has very different policies, or use one of the very many online centric banks which have since popped up and are very customer focused. > I could move to a different city, and the players in this game will change, but the rules, and the outcomes, will remain the same. At least anecdotally, moving from the DC area to Texas changed my life significantly for the better. It moved my friend group for people who were stuck to people who were pushing to accomplish things. It opened up a job market for me personally from a few firms to almost infinite choices. It reduced the cost of buying a house and made it so I could have that as an option. > by powers and circumstances you have absolutely no control over - and by your current personal level of wealth and status You have a lot of control over your money. You can choose to spend it or not spend it, and you can choose how you spend it. You can give up your free time and make more of it, and you can use that free time to make more of it faster. On your point about not being able to tell an unreasonable boss to back off without having money - that's simply not true. I've left a job while basically broke because I felt continuing to work with my employer was unethical. I picked up a lot of odd and un-fun jobs to make it work and it wasn't easy, but I had the choice and I exercised it. Having a choice doesn't mean the choice is easy. It doesn't mean you get to keep your nice car or convenient apartment. Often times choices have consequences and that's OK - that doesn't mean it's not a choice.
- jeffdavis 7y agoMany people in the U.S. get by with limited banking and credit, so consumer businesses are used to dealing with them. Try letting go of the importance of some of the things you are worried about and it might not be as bad as you think. All those businesses that want your SSN will usually accept a deposit instead (yes, even the "big evil" companies that demand it, they will often relent quickly and accept a deposit instead). Get a prepaid phone (again, no SSN). Theoretically, yes, there are lots of problems with banks and credit agencies. But in practice, they don't often interfere with your life if you use them sparingly.
- AstralStorm 7y agoHowever, when they do interfere they're a real pain in the rear. (Second hand: including invalid vindication, account lockouts, wage garnishment.)