3 ms·
There are numerous Irish mutual-aid societies, most of which were set up to offset systematic discrimination against people of Irish descent in earlier times.
by anigbrowl 7y ago
There are numerous Irish mutual-aid societies, most of which were set up to offset systematic discrimination against people of Irish descent in earlier times.
The argument is not that some groups have a sort of ephemeral power. The argument is that they had actual systematic power, and that minorities within a given sphere often lack actual power because their specific needs go overlooked.
Would you join a wheelchair users group and ask for a stairs advocacy subcommittee in the name of equality?
- vorpalhex 7y agoSo help break down this claim for me: > argument is that they had actual systematic power That's the sort of ephemeral power I mention, and that's the kind of claim that requires both evidence and specificity. Do people have that power because of a given trait (their gender, their skin, their nationality), or do they have it by being "the majority"? Does this apply to all majorities? If men of Asian descent are the majority in your field, should you react by having non-Asian focused groups? > minorities within a given sphere often lack actual power because their specific needs go overlooked. Do minorities have fundamentally different needs? Sure in your case of someone who is wheelchair bound that applies, but that doesn't seem to apply to say Brown-eyed software developers (to intentionally choose a non-combustible example). > Would you join a wheelchair users group and ask for a stairs advocacy subcommittee in the name of equality? I don't have an issue with exclusive groups. I have an issue when only some people are allowed to form them. If someone wants to form a stair -championing group, they should be able - even though it's silly. The people who prefer stairs and the people who are unable to use them both have fundamental rights to organize.
- anigbrowl 7y agoI'm not here to spoon-feed you basic concepts. If you find my comment thought provoking you can surely look up phrases like 'systematic discrimination' or 'discrimination against people of Irish descent' and build the necessary context for yourself.
- vorpalhex 7y agoI've read significant portions of Butler's work, most of the basic recommendations on Critical Theory, Legal Critical Theory, and post-third way Progressivism. And to be honest, despite all that, I still genuinely can't comprehend this argument. If you accept this argument (and it seems you do), then I really encourage you to deeply study it's foundations with a critical eye because it rests on a faulty basis.
- anigbrowl 7y agoMy underlying premise, stated as simply as possible, is that when you have rules that disadvantage one group of people over another because of some immutable characteristic, that is unfair and a Bad Thing. You are arguing with a platform I didn't cite and did not have in mind until you mentioned it. Arguments for basic fairness can be found in the Declaration of Independence, the US constitution, and numerous contemporary writings. The academic work you mention seems mostly to be an effort to investigate the degree to which those theoretical concepts are realized in practice.
- reroute1 7y agoBasic concepts != random vague theories
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]