4 ms·
I believe that the left loves to tie itself in knots trying to address the right. Books like What's The Matter with Kansas[1] and The Righteous Mind[2] are all
by jfengel 7y ago
I believe that the left loves to tie itself in knots trying to address the right. Books like What's The Matter with Kansas[1] and The Righteous Mind[2] are all written from a left-wing point of view, explaining the right-wing point of view and encouraging understanding. These books go at least back to the mid 90s[3], and during that time, the Overton window has shifted almost monotonically to the right. It seems to me that the harder the left tries to understand and accommodate the right, the more the right takes it as an opportunity to make itself less appealing to the left. And politically, it's successful.
I don't want to run down a rabbit hole of blame here. Rather, I wanted to suggest that it's not just symmetrical, and it's not as simple as "if only we on the left tried harder we could solve the problem unilaterally" -- because I don't think I've ever heard any similar accommodation from the right. I think we've tried that, and need to try something different.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/What%27s_the_Matter_with_Kansas%3F https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/What%27s_the_Matter_with_Kansa...
[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Righteous_Mind https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Righteous_Mind
[3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Moral_Politics_(book) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Moral_Politics_(book)
- hootbootscoot 7y agoIf you are from or live in the USA you should check out this thing called the "overton window." You don't HAVE any major left-wing political party, only a hard (and growing harder every day, as the John Birchers have taken over Eisenhowers party, but I digress) right wing party and a corporate centrist party, that would be considered center-right by most of the rest of the world (Democrats) I literally am quite convinced that all evil actions emanate from the right wing, good intentions of some notwithstanding. I see absolute evil and a shocking lack of introspection in today's Repugnant party. They teach that environmental stewardship is for suckers, that Donald Trump is God King and above all laws, that laws are for other people, that money SHOULD be in politics (THANK YOU SUPREME COURT citizens united decision, thank you Bush Jr and Trump! Thank you McConnell you filthy scumbag.) I personally feel that hanging is too good for Donald Trump and that he should be publically drawn-and-quartered on live TV, and I'm happy to discuss the reasons why his treasonous contempt for our Republic merits such and how it will bring a cathartic closure to our violent era of empire. I doubt it, however. I would personally love to hear a Republican't whisper "sic semper tyrannus" into Chumps ear while he twists the knife. That disdainful orange blob who poops on all that is good (and cheats at golf) and raises up the wicked for praise and exhaltation should be cast into the lake of fire, forever. However I doubt it. He will probably get away with it, and you fools who support him and pretend you still have a brain cell left in your sycophantic short-sighted heads will nod and say he is a great leader, because you are mean and want to watch the innocent pay for the crimes of the guilty and watch the world burn.... The thing is, you probably feel strongly about your views also (even though you are WRONG ABOUT EVERYTHING, lol) So, where does this leave us?
- hootbootscoot 7y agoHowever, "ranked choice voting"... pretty simple and good idea, yeah?
- jkingsbery 7y agoI can't say I've read any of those books. I can say though that as someone who is more conservative working in tech living in New York City, this doesn't match my daily experience. Pretty frequently, I hear flippant remarks where people assume that everyone else in the room must agree with a particular view or else must be an idiot. And my experience from trying to break out of my bubble by reading left-leaning material is that even if there are examples of books out there in which a leftist tries to explain conservatives to other leftists, they seem to have little impact on the general discourse. I don't think it's a simple case that the Overton Window has moved to the right. When one reads for example the Democratic party platform of the 1990's, many of the proposals are more similar to what some Republicans argue for today. In any case, my point is: maybe conservatives are to blame. Conservatives are roughly half the country. If the author wants to make some change, he'll half to convince at least some of that half. Speaking only to the favored half won't change anything.