3 ms·
Just a cursory look over history and you see how many cultural things are traded and etc. It seems untenable for folks to claim a thing, let alone figure out
by duxup 7y ago
Just a cursory look over history and you see how many cultural things are traded and etc. It seems untenable for folks to claim a thing, let alone figure out who then gets to claim it considering the vaugnesses of race and backgrounds.
I also worry that the effort to clam ownership or whatever we want to call it actually just creates more isolation.
A local educational institution used a local native american symbol for a long time. It was always done respectfully (no weird chanting or anything). One tribe even regularly sent drummers and dancers to open sporting events. It was a really cool thing to see / be a part of, everyone had a great time in a community that didn't have much in the way of connections between the tribal entities and etc.
But it was decided that the local tribes should vote on if it should continue or not. One tribe overwhelmingly voted yes. Another tribe due to tribal politics chose not to vote. So out went the tradition, away went what was one of the few connections between the reservations and non reservations. I think it was a great loss.
- celticmusic 7y agoI don't know that I buy the symbol created connections. You could just as easily continue the traditions without the symbol, unless it was the entirety of the traditions themselves that was voted out? I mean, I agree with your overall point, I just don't think any specific symbol is really that important, well outside of a few notable exceptions. To me it's like saying the fact that I can't display the word "Hello", which is itself a form of symbolism, is somehow going to destroy the community. If the community is destroyed, it wasn't the symbol, or lack thereof, that did it.