4 ms·
Every prison guard in the world “learns” that almost every convict is innocent and is there by accident. While Guantanamo methods are supposedly shady (and ill
by wruza 7y ago
Every prison guard in the world “learns” that almost every convict is innocent and is there by accident.
While Guantanamo methods are supposedly shady (and illegal in light of basic human rights and conventions), there is a very non-zero chance that the article is a made up and/or incomplete story by this convict. I’m not going to claim anything, but let’s not jump to conclusions on who is real evil based only on what someone says on the internet out of a prison cell.
It may sound hard for this guy, but if he’s innocent, he is still outnumbered by cynical liars who claim the same everyday. They have time at their hands to figure out ways to make life easier and constant deception is one of the methods used.
Iow, one of the answers on why it’s not a daily headline is because UN, human rights and those who make headlines check a little deeper -or- put it under “opinion” tag (like in this article).
- jacquesm 7y agoYou did note that in the meantime the real person he was mistaken for was also arrested?
- beerandt 7y agoI think this might play into the claim of innocence, as sort of a misdirect / false equivalence. They might have mistaken him initially for someone else, but it doesn't seem like his real identity is really an innocent bystander.
- jacquesm 7y ago> it doesn't seem like his real identity is really an innocent bystander. So, let me try to follow your reasoning: (1) he was arrested because of a case of mistaken identity (2) the person he was mistaken for was arrested later and positively identified (3) he must have been guilty of something because he was arrested I'm really not following, care to explain?
- beerandt 7y agoIt looks like he was an accomplice to the person they originally mistook him for. Not just a random taxi driver / guy in the street. They mistook him because of where he was and what he was doing, presumably running a safe house and being (taxi?) driver to senior operatives. Not mistaken because of looks, and maybe not as innocent as he makes it sound in the article. He's not the bad guy they originally thought he was, but still a bad guy, or at least was working for the bad guy. Not advocating for torture, and not necessarily saying it's true, just presenting the other side. https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/a/af/ISN_01461%2C_Mohammed_Ahmad_Rabbani%27s_Guantanamo_detainee_assessment.pdf https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/a/af/ISN_0146...
- jacquesm 7y agoThere is no other side: either they arrested him for cause or they did not. Arresting someone thinking they are someone else should automatically result in a release and in this case probably compensation. You are 'just presenting the other side' in the same way that news organizations will pretend to be balanced by presenting two sides of an argument which has already been resolved as though there is some kind of controversy that needs to be kept alive. So, either he was 'a bad guy', let's see the charges, or it was a case of mistaken identity. It does not look like there is much middle ground here.
- beerandt 7y ago1) If the cops get a tip that Bonnie is hiding out in a house, and they raid it only to find Clyde alone, they're going to still arrest him. Even if it takes them time to figure out that Clyde is -in fact- Clyde, and that he isn't Bonnie. Same goes for a senior member of Al Qaeda and his driver/messenger/accomplice. 2) This isn't about his character or being "good" vs "bad". This is about whether he knowingly provided material support to Al Qaeda or enemy combatants. The leaked report I linked to makes a compelling (to me) case that he repeatedly attempted to join and assist militant jihad groups, including after being jailed for it in Pakistan. 3) That said, none of it justifies torture, and none of it justifies denying him the right to a trial, be it military or civilian.
- wruza 7y agoIf you was mistaken for someone else that doesn’t automagically free you from crimes or connections you have yourself, apart from that person. The story doesn’t tell us how he got caught. Was he kidnapped at night from his family or busted at a secret meeting after a two-month intelligence operation - this can make a big difference. I think you did read my comment as a definitive statement, while it just describes an option that was not mentioned itt, but has some potential to be true.
- sangnoir 7y ago> If you was mistaken for someone else that doesn’t automagically free you from crimes or connections you have yourself, apart from that person Wow. I have seen this attitude deployed by law enforcement against certain demographics "Well, he might not have committed this crime, but he committed some other crime for sure. Pinning this on him is no biggie, he had it coming". This attitude makes a mockery of any nation that considers itself a nation ruled by law - that is not the way the law should work
- wruza 7y agoWell, he might not have committed this crime, but he committed some other crime for sure. Pinning this on him is no biggie, he had it coming That’s bad, but I can’t see this “attitude” in my comments. I thought I put enough “one of maybe possible, chances are, explanation”. This is not what I meant. Speaking about versions and possibilities is not the same as acting solely out of these.
- koonsolo 7y agoWho is to say someone is innocent or not? In the western world there is still a thing called "Innocent until proven guilty", and that proof is done in court. 17 years without a trial is not acceptable by any western values.
- krapp 7y ago>17 years without a trial is not acceptable by any western values. You may not have noticed, but Western values have changed. Indefinite detainment without trial and torture are perfectly acceptable for Muslims and brown people. If Guantanamo Bay ever harms one hair on a pretty Christian white girl's head, though, Americans will burn it to the ground.
- nzealand 7y ago71 detainees were classified as too dangerous to be transferred from Guantanamo, even though there was no evidence to justify laying charges against them. Mohammed Ahmad Ghulam Rabbani was one of the 71 individuals deemed too innocent to charge, but too dangerous to release.