4 ms·
STEM people have a real blind spot with this. Who runs the world? Not STEM people. Most politicians have a legal and/or liberal background. They may also have
by TheOtherHobbes 7y ago
STEM people have a real blind spot with this.
Who runs the world? Not STEM people. Most politicians have a legal and/or liberal background. They may also have a background in STEM - particularly likely in Europe, less so in the US - but you get nowhere in politics without studying and understanding foundational liberal arts skills such as rhetoric, persuasion, and public debate.
The idea that liberal arts majors spend their entire time writing on essentially useless activities - like post-structural critiques of famous literature - is hilariously naive.
Some liberal arts academics do indeed do this, but that's because the liberal arts have pure and applied elements. Just like STEM. And STEM academics also spend their time on wildly impractical theoretical pastimes.
But at the applied end, the liberal arts run the planet. They don't keep the lights on - engineers do that - but they set the policy goals and define the political, economic, moral, and philosophical orthodoxies that virtually everyone conforms to, whether or not they're consciously aware of it.
- H_Pylori 7y ago>But at the applied end, the liberal arts run the planet. They don't keep the lights on - engineers do that - but they set the policy goals and define the political, economic, moral, and philosophical orthodoxies that virtually everyone conforms to, whether or not they're consciously aware of it. In my country most politicians have a liberal background. Also nuclear power is illegal here. Coincidence? I think not.
- majos 7y ago> you get nowhere in politics without studying and understanding foundational liberal arts skills such as rhetoric, persuasion, and public debate I’m skeptical that attainment of political power is easily attributed to a good liberal arts education. I think desire for power, some intelligence, and a relaxed relationship with principles go a long way. Well-crafted rhetoric...eh.
- AstralStorm 7y agoA lot of practice comes a long way. A few truly top politicians were also actors. (Not necessarily very good ones.)
- SuoDuanDao 7y agoFunnily enough, most politicians* are from law backgrounds... which while it falls on the 'arts' side of the spectrum is definitely a specialized field and vocation. I suspect that the dichotomy isn't so much 'STEM vs Arts' but 'Accountable vs Unaccountable'. Most STEM fields are accountable to reality and future employers, and law is similarly accountable to rival scholars of law and employers of new lawyers. That makes law a rather noteworthy outlier in the liberal arts. *in western countries
- AstralStorm 7y agoAnd quite a few politicians have an equivalent of economics degree. Those fields are in neighborhood of STEM more than old "liberal arts" standard of language, foreign language, art (painting or music) and history. (Note: no ethics or philosophy.)
- triceratops 7y agoPhysics, math, chemistry, logic, biology, history, geography, geology, astronomy, even economics are "accountable to reality". They are all liberal arts. Your idea of liberal arts is incomplete.
- SuoDuanDao 7y agoAre you accepting the dichotomy of STEM and Liberal Arts, and then categorising math as a liberal art? Do you know the M in STEM stands for 'Mathematics'?
- triceratops 7y agoI think it's pretty clear from my posts that I'm not accepting this dichotomy - the "S" is science. Most sciences and math are firmly in the realm of liberal arts. I believe the argument is over how much T & E there needs to be in school and college education.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]