3 ms·
> In practice, modern “liberal arts” programs often dispense with logic, math, and empirical science...it’s insufficient to throw in a few courses on math that
by triceratops 7y ago
> In practice, modern “liberal arts” programs often dispense with logic, math, and empirical science...it’s insufficient to throw in a few courses on math that everyone quickly forgets.
Where are you getting any of this from? What in the world are you talking about?
Since you mentioned Georgia Tech, I looked up their liberal arts programs at the undergraduate and graduate level.
Selected undergrad majors: Computational Media (computer science and design)[1], Economics (pretty mathy, check out the curriculum[2]), Global Economics and Languages (ditto [3]).
Selected graduate majors: Digital Media (tons of programming and design work[4]), Human Computer Interaction (tech-y by definition [5]), Economics, Infosec [6]. Seems like any of those degrees would require plenty of "logic, math, and empirical science".
But then one might say, "Georgia Tech is an engineering school. Of course their liberal arts stuff is going to be tinged with rigor. But them lefty, coastal, liberal hotbeds can't reason their way out of a paper bag."
So I looked up Wellesley College, one such institution. They offer majors in such soft disciplines as Astronomy, Physics, Astrophysics, Biochemistry, Math, Chemistry, Biology, Computer Science, Geosciences, to name a few.[7] They graduate students in these majors every year.
I don't think you understand the breadth of disciplines that a liberal arts education can encompass. There are liberal arts degrees attained by taking the bare minimum of math, or science classes and then there are liberal arts degrees such as geology that have plenty of hard (haha!) science and math behind them.
> consider how kids learn about history. They read stories, mostly focused on individuals. But that’s not the only way to learn history. I took a class at Georgia Tech in the history of science, which looked at the impact on society of various technological advances
What does a class you took at Georgia Tech have to do with how kids are taught history in school? They are different things. Kids being taught history poorly doesn't invalidate the importance of the subject. Kids are taught math and science poorly too.
Advanced studies in history do explore questions of the sort you raised.
> Math, science, and logic should be the basic foundation for cultivating children’s world view, not literature, philosophy, or social studies.
I think philosophy and social studies are just as important as math and science, and maybe literature is less important. First off, logic has its roots in philosophy[8]. Social studies such as history, civics, and geography are important for a well-informed citizenry. Economics is pretty handy. You may scoff at literature as being useless, but it forms the basis of the entertainment industry - plenty of money there.
1. https://www.iac.gatech.edu/academics/undergraduate/bs/cm https://www.iac.gatech.edu/academics/undergraduate/bs/cm
2. https://www.iac.gatech.edu/academics/undergraduate/bs/economics https://www.iac.gatech.edu/academics/undergraduate/bs/econom...
3. https://www.iac.gatech.edu/academics/undergraduate/bs/geml https://www.iac.gatech.edu/academics/undergraduate/bs/geml
4. https://dm.lmc.gatech.edu/program/courses-2/ https://dm.lmc.gatech.edu/program/courses-2/
5. http://www.mshci.gatech.edu/program/about http://www.mshci.gatech.edu/program/about
6. https://www.iac.gatech.edu/academics/graduate https://www.iac.gatech.edu/academics/graduate
7. https://www.wellesley.edu/academics/deptsmajorprog https://www.wellesley.edu/academics/deptsmajorprog
8. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Logic https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Logic
- ggggtez 7y agoThere is an issue of terminology happening here. While Georgia Tech might have a "Liberal Arts College", that's not the same thing as a "Liberal Arts degree". From wikipedia: "There is no formal definition of liberal arts college". Here's someone else explaining better than I can: "A bachelor's degree in liberal arts means that the courses you take will be in general areas of study such as philosophy, mathematics, literature, art history, or languages, rather than in applied or specialized fields." If you think that Biochemistry is a "liberal arts degree" then you've really misunderstood what the above poster was talking about. Biochemistry is a specialized field, and no one would consider that a liberal arts subject. If it helps, you want to be looking towards degrees like: psychology, business, literature, arts, sociology, women's studies, languages, history, political science... Does this mean these degrees will never touch math? By no means! But it's foolish to think the level of mathematical and technical rigor would be similar to a degree in, say, Physics. Generally speaking, even a Physics student will take some liberal arts classes as electives, as part of a "liberal arts education"; what we might call well-rounded. But while the physics student might read a few books and find it interesting, and keep that as part of them for the rest of their life... it's generally not the case that a student of Fine Arts is going to take Calculus and occasionally wistfully perform derivatives.
- TheOtherHobbes 7y agoSTEM people have a real blind spot with this. Who runs the world? Not STEM people. Most politicians have a legal and/or liberal background. They may also have a background in STEM - particularly likely in Europe, less so in the US - but you get nowhere in politics without studying and understanding foundational liberal arts skills such as rhetoric, persuasion, and public debate. The idea that liberal arts majors spend their entire time writing on essentially useless activities - like post-structural critiques of famous literature - is hilariously naive. Some liberal arts academics do indeed do this, but that's because the liberal arts have pure and applied elements. Just like STEM. And STEM academics also spend their time on wildly impractical theoretical pastimes. But at the applied end, the liberal arts run the planet. They don't keep the lights on - engineers do that - but they set the policy goals and define the political, economic, moral, and philosophical orthodoxies that virtually everyone conforms to, whether or not they're consciously aware of it.