9 ms·
This is wrong on two levels. First: > My objection is that all this talk about STEM is just the latest way to keep our schools focused exclusively on vocation
by rayiner 7y ago
This is wrong on two levels.
First:
> My objection is that all this talk about STEM is just the latest way to keep our schools focused exclusively on vocational training, to prepare our children for those mythological "jobs of tomorrow," jobs that may exist today
My first grader is going to college in 11 years. 11 years ago was 2009. The jobs were more or less the same. She’ll be graduated in 15. 15 years ago was 2005. The jobs were the same.
Second: the article conflates STEM with vocational training. It’s not. It’s an alternative framework to the “liberal arts education.” Even if the “jobs of tomorrow” are different, a STEM education will prepare kids for it better than a liberal arts education. The idea that a "liberal arts education" is the "all purpose flour" of education is obsolete. It's an artifact of the culture of western aristocrats.
> No, the purpose of education in a democracy ought to be to prepare children for their role as citizens and that means that they learn to think for themselves, that they ask a lot of questions, that they question authority, that they stand up for what they believe in, and that they understand that their contribution to the world cannot be measured in money
A STEM education is better for that too! Citizens who cannot think about the world in numeric and statistical terms are not prepared to understand it, or the complex choices facing them.
> I did not enter the teaching game to prepare young children for their role in the economy
Teachers are deeply confused about their role. They're public employees who are hired to prepare kids for the work force because that is what taxpayers pay them to do. We don't spend $1 trillion a year on public education to have teachers indoctrinate kids on their philosophical and political views. (Now that I have my own kids in school, I understand why my mom, moving to the US from an Asian country 30 years ago, was so befuddled by the education I was receiving.)
- nikofeyn 7y agothis is an incredibly disheartening comment.
- mango7283 7y ago>Now that I have my own kids in school, I understand why my mom, moving to the US from an Asian country 30 years ago, was so befuddled by the education I was receiving.) Schools in East Asia, alongside pushing STEM topics are still also vehicles for pushing the philosophical and cultural views of the state through the teachers and curriculum, so I'm not sure why this is befuddling as such. For a concrete example see Chinese medium schools in Malaysia, where it's not just about them being ostensibly better at teaching math or other STEM topics, but about Chinese language as a proxy for Chinese culture and values.
- rayiner 7y ago> Schools in East Asia, alongside pushing STEM topics are still also vehicles for pushing the philosophical and cultural views of the state through the teachers and curriculum, so I'm not sure why this is befuddling as such. Schools in the US, at least in theory, don’t teach the philosophical and cultural views of the society. This is a concession to the fact that the US is a multi-cultural society, so teaching values as such would be inappropriate. Kids therefore get some instruction in US history, civics, and government, but you can get through the whole sequence without learning anything about Christianity or Western Europe.
- mango7283 7y agoAh so what you meant is your mother was befuddled that US schools were non ideological?
- fiblye 7y ago>This is a concession to the fact that the US is a multi-cultural society, so teaching values as such would be inappropriate. That in itself is teaching values. From kindergarten and up, American schools teach students that diversity is a great thing, and we're all equal, and it's what makes America so special. It's something we're taught to be aware of and cherish. That's something loads of other countries' public education systems don't teach at all, and some even teach the opposite. How a country teaches values isn't obvious to someone raised within that country. It's just thought to be common sense.
- triceratops 7y ago> Citizens who cannot think about the world in numeric and statistical terms are not prepared to understand it, or the complex choices facing them... We don't spend $1 trillion a year on public education to have teachers indoctrinate kids on their philosophical and political views. I think the "liberal" in "liberal arts" is throwing you off :-P. Math, stats, and logic is very much part of a liberal arts education.[1] So are life and natural sciences, philosophy, history, geography, and political science. I would imagine learning all of these would make you a better informed citizen. 1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Liberal_arts_education#Modern_usage https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Liberal_arts_education#Modern_...
- throwaway100773 7y agoI have a Bachelor of Arts in Mathematics.
- rayiner 7y agoFrom that link: > In the Renaissance, the Italian humanists and their Northern counterparts, despite in many respects continuing the traditions of the Middle Ages, reversed that process. Re-christening the old trivium with a new and more ambitious name: Studia humanitatis, and also increasing its scope, they downplayed logic as opposed to the traditional Latin grammar and rhetoric, and added to them history, Greek, and moral philosophy (ethics), with a new emphasis on poetry as well. In practice, modern “liberal arts” programs often dispense with logic, math, and empirical science. Again, from your link: > For example, the core courses for Georgetown University's Doctor of Liberal Studies program cover philosophy, theology, history, art, literature, and the social sciences. More fundamentally, it’s insufficient to throw in a few courses on math that everyone quickly forgets. Math, science, and logic should be the basic foundation for cultivating children’s world view, not literature, philosophy, or social studies. For example, consider how kids learn about history. They read stories, mostly focused on individuals. But that’s not the only way to learn history. I took a class at Georgia Tech in the history of science, which looked at the impact on society of various technological advances. History education doesn’t quantify anything. But we have lots of data. What was the GDP per capita of ancient Egypt versus Mesopotamia? What are quantitative indicators we can use to help put those societies into context and compare them with ours? what was the infant mortality rate in India before and after British colonization? What were the demographic trends in Mandate Palestine prior to the creation of Israel?
- thrower123 7y agoThe thing that drives me nuts is that it is always presented as this dichotomy between teaching STEM and teaching liberal arts, as if you have to pick one or the other. The schools have these children for twelve or thirteen years. You could easily do both if you cut the shit and the nonsense and didn't waste their time. You might have to track children according to ability, which is unpalatable to some. You might also have to have a revolution in the art of teacher education and practice, which is probably impossible due to the entrenched interests.
- porknubbins 7y agoYou could teach some motivated fraction of children orders of magnitude more academic information but the goal of primary education is equally if not more to socialize them into being what the society demands of its citizens. Seeing foreign elementary schools hammered this home for me, what I’d forgotten or assimilated so much I didn’t even notice it- that teachers are constantly reinforcing their normative values about whats good and bad behavior. Because this varies so much by culture its wild to see for example a Japanese elementary school.
- Fomite 7y agoCitizens who cannot think about the world in philosophical, historical and ethical terms are not prepared to understand it, or the complex choices facing them. ~ STEM Professor.
- elfexec 7y ago> 11 years ago was 2009. Now that's depressing. > It's an artifact of the culture of western aristocrats. There are elements of truth in what you said. But liberal education is also the bedrock of western education and knowledge which includes STEM fields. Every stem field was created and advanced by those who came from "liberal arts education". Also, liberal arts education has always included math and science. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Liberal_arts_education https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Liberal_arts_education Liberal arts education created the western world order. It's why the west is on top. It would be counterproductive to discard it. Perhaps we should just increase the share of STEM within the overall liberal arts education system?
- username90 7y ago> Also, liberal arts education has always included math and science. Math and physics are solidly on the STEM side when people argue the merits of STEM vs liberal arts. So instead of arguing semantics, understand what people mean. When they say "Don't study STEM, study liberal arts" what they mean is not "Don't study the more practical sides of STEM like engineering, study the liberal arts side of STEM like Maths", but instead "Don't study anything which requires more math than Algebra 1".
- elfexec 7y ago> Math and physics are solidly on the STEM side when people argue the merits of STEM vs liberal arts. That's my point. I disagree with the assertion that STEM is separate from liberal arts education. Historically it hasn't been true. And it's not true today. > So instead of arguing semantics, understand what people mean. Not arguing semantics. I understand what people mean and I am disagreeing with them and I provided sources and historical proof. > When they say "Don't study STEM, study liberal arts" Who says don't study STEM, study liberal arts? > but instead "Don't study anything which requires more math than Algebra 1". You've built up an exaggeration of the side you are arguing against. That's not an honest portrayal of the issue at hand. You can study both science/engineering/etc and history/philosphy/politics/etc. It's called getting a well rounded liberal arts education. The backbone of science, technology, engineering and math along with philosophy, history, politics, etc. My suggestion was increase the amount of "STEM" within the liberal arts education system we already have - particularly the technology and engineering. It's not an either-or issue that people like to portray it as.
- ggggtez 7y ago> I did not enter the teaching game to prepare young children for their role in the economy The guy is a preschool teacher. Let's be honest, he's not really in the 'teaching game' anyway.
- Psyladine 7y agoMy son learned letters, numbers, colors, shapes, could count to 100 and add two digit numbers as a result of his preschooling and was just beginning subtraction when he entered kindergarten.
- ggggtez 7y agoI don't get your point. So you think the ability to teach a child what color is "red" and what color is "blue", gives you the background to make blanket statements about science education and jobs?
- Psyladine 7y agoIt's an arrogant dismissal to say early education is not serious education. The house built on sand will not stand... Take your view of the author's lack of meaningful credentials regarding teaching to its logical conclusion...we ought to not have any classes except the final ones, so no math education, except for the last most advanced calculus courses, because math before that isn't really in the 'teaching game'. You can immediately see how abrupt and flawed that approach would be. If anything, the greatest care is needed in the first steps.
- ggggtez 7y agoOh please. Your slippery slope argument is garbage. The truth is, only ~33% of 4 year-olds even attend preschool in the US [1]. So by the facts of reality, preschool is completely optional. Plenty of people go on to get college degrees without going to pre-school and it's ridiculous to claim it's the same as skipping high school. Speaking of college... Unlike for real teachers, only half of public preschool programs require any sort of degree or qualification, and this guy works for a private preschool, which often have no requirements at all. Indeed, after a difficult search, I found that he actually never finished college [2]. So yeah, he's basically just a random guy with no official background in education. So who the fuck cares about his opinion about STEM in education? He got the job because his daughter went to the preschool. That's it. That's not a qualification. [1] https://www.statista.com/statistics/315074/percentage-of-pre-school-enrollment-in-the-us-by-age-and-type/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/315074/percentage-of-pre... [2] https://artfulparent.com/teacher-tom-on-child-led-learning/ https://artfulparent.com/teacher-tom-on-child-led-learning/
- thundergolfer 7y agoTeaching students non-STEM stuff isn’t indoctrination by teachers into those teachers personal political and philosophical views. Do you seriously think that’s what goes on? I did music, foreign languages, philosophy, art, business studies in a public high school in Australia. These subjects, obviously, had a state wide curriculum. I was not indoctrinated by my teachers.
- rayiner 7y agoThat’s exactly what the article describes as going on: > No, the purpose of education in a democracy ought to be to prepare children for their role as citizens and that means that they learn to think for themselves, that they ask a lot of questions, that they question authority, that they stand up for what they believe in, and that they understand that their contribution to the world cannot be measured in money. This is indoctrination into a specific value system.[1] None of this is necessary to teach kids math or writing, logical analysis, data analysis, or even the functioning of our government. [1] As an Asian immigrant, it’s also largely not the value system I want to teach my kids. I’d rather have kids learn to respect authority, to respect the wishes and preferences of the majority of people around them, to be very considerate of how their actions affect others, to keep their heads down and work hard, to fully understand why things are the way they are before advocating for change, and that their function as people is to contribute to economy and thus the society and get a well paying job so they can support their own families. I strongly suspect that for most Americans, or at least a large swath of Americans, the values they want to teach their kids hew closer to the above than “question authority.”
- thundergolfer 7y ago> Indoctrination (noun) - the process of teaching a person or group to accept a set of beliefs uncritically. I understand what you're saying about conflicting value systems, but you're flat-out wrong that what the author describes is indoctrination. The key word from the definition is "uncritically". Here's the key part of what you've quoted: > they learn to think for themselves, that they ask a lot of questions, that they question authority, All that is the opposite of "accepting uncritically".