4 ms·
I think she’s referring to the social engineering part of the activity of getting people on the inside to open up and give up company information. From a psych
by mc32 7y ago
I think she’s referring to the social engineering part of the activity of getting people on the inside to open up and give up company information.
From a psychological perspective she’s probably right. The results sought are obviously quite different.
- duxup 7y agoI feel like the comparison to adults talking to each other ... and someone grooming someone underage. That's just way too distant psychology wise. Generally the implication of the adult and child situation is some sort of distinct power advantage the adult has.
- mirimir 7y agoWell, except that it's not just children who are victims of sexual predation. For example, I recall a recent article that basically redefined seduction as sexual predation.
- justincredible 7y agoYour first statement is correct, but that article is a ludicrous example.
- mirimir 7y agoEdit: OK, I'm wrong about the article. It's about Gabriel Matzneff "seducing" young girls: > It is only a shocking new #MeToo memoir by one of his victims, Vanessa Springora–seduced by Matzneff when she was 13, and he almost 50–that has prodded French conscience on the question of sexual consent to a point of no return. But about the term generally:[1] > As the issue of sexual predation in the workplace has become increasingly prominent, there are calls to provide employees with special training to minimize this behavior in the future. 0) https://www.forbes.com/sites/tamarathiessen/2020/01/21/gabriel-matzneff-french-furore-on-acclaimed-writers-child-sex-abuse-4-decades-on/ https://www.forbes.com/sites/tamarathiessen/2020/01/21/gabri... 1) https://www.psychologytoday.com/us/blog/inside-the-criminal-mind/201712/the-thinking-processes-sexual-predators https://www.psychologytoday.com/us/blog/inside-the-criminal-...
- mc32 7y agoBut psychologically it’s not all that different from being a con between adults. Even though adults get ripped off by cons it doesn’t mean that it’s “alright”. It’s all using particular psychology to get the confidence of a target. Her language is indeed inflammatory but still the tools used are similar but obviously for a different purpose.
- duxup 7y agoI'm not convinced anyone leaking information from their workplace is a "con". I think plenty of folks out there are leaking information because they want to. I doubt many qualify as a "con". Maybe if the bos "Meg" comes to them and knows about it they claim they were conned, but these are adults, I don't think the situation is that much of a mystery to them.
- HenryBemis 7y agoI know Meg, she wouldn't mean it in a way "journalists are rapists" but more like "journalists/corporate espionage are relentless (with the same intensity) as sexual predators" in the pursuit of company secrets". I remember there was a couple of similar incidents issue while in HP, so she's been burnt before. Edit: added a couple of words for clarity
- duxup 7y ago"similar incidents issue while in HP" Considering the politics at HP and all the crazy things that happened, I'm not sure journalists were were even required to get less than positive news out of HP. Plenty of folks inside HP playing games there before and after she left.
- HenryBemis 7y agoIt wasn't "positive news", there were some things that we planned to be announce at a certain date/time (e.g. Monday after NYSE trading closing) and they would be leaked on Friday or during the weekend. And some sensitive news (e.g. M&A's).
- danharaj 7y agoDon't compare decent people to sexual predators, tho?
- sneak 7y agoAdults can consent. An adult choosing to say yes or no is a voluntary interaction. Childrens’ minds have not fully developed yet, and are vulnerable to adults exerting power over them. Apples and Oranges. This argument is an example of sophistry: clever, but totally incorrect. Don’t be taken in by it. The crime that is grooming a child using a power imbalance has nothing to do whatsoever with the voluntary interaction between a member of the press and their adult source.
- pmarreck 7y agoDoes every power imbalance break consent? Or does it depend on the degree of power imbalance? How is "power" objectively measured to compute whether consent is violated or not? To use a trite example, older wealthy middlingly-attractive gentleman and younger much poorer but very attractive woman? What about boss and secretary? What if the latter results in a stable marriage? (I know of at least one such...) What if it is (to stir the pot further) the Mary Kay Letourneau- Vili Fualaau marriage? The reason why I ask is that while I believe that in principle, the concept of consent exists, it seems to me that applying it in practice is fraught with things such as fallacious appeals to disgust, belief-infused moral prognostications/judgments and whatnot, and it's just occurred to me that a large part of the difficulty may simply be how to objectively evaluate every consensual exchange to see if consent has been violated or not. Perhaps a framework already exists for just such a need... just throwing this out there.
- mc32 7y agoThere are legal definitions that society draws from a lot, both for underage and for people whose mental condition is such they are incapable of giving consent. But aside from that people get manipulated through cons to give consent where they might not. (Fraudulent marriages, etc.)
- pmarreck 7y agoBut isn't a "con" better classified as a deception? I don't think the marriages with big age disparities (and possibly power exchanges going on) were necessarily based on deception