6 ms·
I'm sure these SEO finds follow the rule of cockroaches... For every one you see, there's a dozen more that you don't see. I'm sure this makes it frustrating
by nostromo 16y ago
I'm sure these SEO finds follow the rule of cockroaches... For every one you see, there's a dozen more that you don't see. I'm sure this makes it frustrating for everyone who's playing the game legitimately. If one guy jumps the turnstile in the Subway, it's fine. If everyone jumps the turnstile, you feel like a chump for paying your fare.
I'm starting to think that Google's influence on the web is more and more negative. By giving an economic value to a link, spam is rampant. I run a coding wiki, and every day there are dozens of spammers flooding in no matter what kind of wall I put up (nofollow, capture, delay in posting, ip blacklisting...). All of these walls are bad for users and discourage participation. Websites are now being coded more for Googlebot than humans. Every link is treated as suspect. No-follow was supposed to help, but from the looks of it, spammers don't care since they get paid by the link.
We desperately need an end to the pagerank monoculture; either from Google or from their competitors. Hopefully it's replaced by a truly open standard, and not a walled garden like Facebook.
- Natsu 16y agoYou're right about the cockroach rule. It's not just you facing wiki vandalism en masse, incidentally. Lately, I've been amusing myself by looking into a group that has been vandalizing hundreds if not thousands of wikis in order to create a fake "community" relevant to certain juicy SEO terms (jobs, porn, counterfeit luxury goods, and viagra, mostly). They appear to all be working together to promote http://starsea http://starsea rchtool.com/ (link deliberately broken). They have so many links that I should probably code my own bot to follow them. They might be promoting other pages that I don't know about, too. After all, they can easily change their code to link to anyone they want to. It's quite a mess. Some people have just deleted their wikis in frustration, others have fought back by banning spambot accounts en masse, and some are still oblivious to the fact that their wikis are now filled with spam pages. I've followed the spam around, tried to clue people in, submitted some reports via Google's feedback page, etc., but I'm not sure how much good it's doing.
- Matt_Cutts 16y agoWe'll check that out--thanks for mentioning it. Feel free to write up something on the web and tweet me a link to it, if you want to send more details.
- Natsu 16y agoI'm just glad to know it's getting some attention. They attacked a small game wiki I use and I started to get alarmed once I realized the scale of their operation. I don't know if you got it, but I wrote down a bunch of URLs for spammed-up wikis and some information on one of the Google feedback forms a few days back. I realize that that kind of thing can be lost in the noise, though. EDIT: Here's one search that will show you a (now deleted) wiki that was spam-filled. You can follow the links on the spam pages to other vandalized wikis. http://google.com/search?q=site%3Apreventioncommunities.com+jobs http://google.com/search?q=site%3Apreventioncommunities.com+...
- Natsu 16y agoI finished a more complete writeup and sent it to you. There's probably nothing you couldn't figure out from that spam-filled search alone, but maybe it'll save you guys some time.
- brown9-2 16y agoHow do you propose solving the problem of helping people find what they are searching for if it doesn't involve a search engine? As long as there are search engines, there will be algorithms that people try to game. And as long as people need help finding things, there will be search engines. It seems the only way around this would be to remove the ability to make money on the Internet.