3 ms·
Air-quality safety (among other things) is assured by the EPA, and it's done a lot to undermine that trust in the last couple of decades. Electronics safety is
by samatman 7y ago
Air-quality safety (among other things) is assured by the EPA, and it's done a lot to undermine that trust in the last couple of decades.
Electronics safety is assured by UL, a private company. To date, they've maintained the public's trust in their services.
If Consumer Reports publishes an exposé of UL taking kickbacks to certify substandard equipment, I'd become very interested in buying gear certified by a competitor.
With the EPA, I mean... I can't vote out the leadership of the EPA. I can very indirectly vote for a change there, and hope it happens, if that vote happens to align with my other interest, but there's no granularity, no way to hit them in their pocketbook, which I line once a year regardless of my feelings on the matter.
Now, there are some immediate differences between the two, which are obvious enough that I'm not going to bother elucidating them. But it's an instructive comparison. I'd say the UL model is underutilized.
- toasterlovin 7y ago> I'd become very interested in buying gear certified by a competitor. UL’s main competitor is ETL. I can tell you that you very much should prefer products tested by UL. I work for a company that makes wire and it’s widely know inside our industry that ETL does nothing to ensure that products being sold with their mark are products they actually tested. There are lots of issues with UL’s enforcement of their mark, but ETL just doesn’t care at all.
- horsawlarway 7y agoI find this comparison dead on arrival. Full stop. UL, a private company, can only exist because they charge manufacturers of electronics for their certification. No one is manufacturing the air we breathe (at least not yet...) so there is no revenue source for this kind of testing outside of public funding. Your whole comment is a classic example of attempting to apply market forces to a problem that has no market. I'll be blunt - Capitalism is a nifty trick for situations where there's a market and low barrier to entry. IT IS NOT A SILVER BULLET.
- ibeckermayer 7y agoAir safety certification could be seen as a market, with the buyers being localities (towns, cities, city-states, counties, etc). I don’t think the issue is so much “markets vs govt” as it is accountability vs impunity. The issue with single-payer, nationalized air protection is that there’s a single point of failure and there’s no reasonable means of individual dissent (pulling funding, voting with one’s feet, etc). Of course this line of thinking leads to some very politically incorrect conclusions.
- thewebcount 7y agoMost people don't know what UL is or that they even exist. Of the few who do, many probably believe it's some government mandated thing. Regardless, just because UL seems to be doing a decent job (I'm not really qualified to comment on that, just going on an assumption here), there have been other industry groups that were supposed to do the same thing and were basically utter failures. For example, the EnergyStar organization giving certification for a gasoline powered alarm clock[0]. [0] https://gizmodo.com/a-fake-gas-powered-alarm-clock-once-got-energy-star-cer-1656128986 https://gizmodo.com/a-fake-gas-powered-alarm-clock-once-got-...
- samatman 7y ago> Energy Star was started in 1992 by the EPA as a voluntary labeling program to encourage the consumption of more energy-efficient appliances. Huh! TIL.