5 ms·
TL;DR - Loads of organizational problems, disincentives, and cultural problems make this job hard, and nobody who can do anything about it listens. There's als
by zdw 16y ago
TL;DR - Loads of organizational problems, disincentives, and cultural problems make this job hard, and nobody who can do anything about it listens. There's also not enough money.
- andyv 16y agoThe author seemed to think that more money would fix the problem as well. But the faith in money to fix things is pretty blind-- the only thing that fixes problems are people who care, and anyone who tries here will end up in a fight with the people who don't care. Pay them enough money and they'll start caring? Yea, right.
- maxxxxx 16y ago"Pay them enough money and they'll start caring? Yea, right". We should tell the same to CEOs and bankers.
- andyv 16y agoBut if CEOs and banker fail to please their customers, the company will do badly, and their boards will fire them. Government schools have no such constraints. They can waste money with impunity.
- intended 16y agoWell this guy looks like he does care. (keeps dry fruits to help the kids out) Money would definitely help fix the broken roof, bad heating, broken printers and help keep stocks of paper at the least. Possibly better pipes too. It seems that you are saying that more cash will not help with the problems he has described. Could you clarify why having more cash will not help?
- RiderOfGiraffes 16y agoMore cash won't stop the kids from stealing, accusing the teachers of inappropriate behavior, or vandalism. More cash won't make the kids stop bringing knives into school, won't make them want to learn, won't make them behave in class, and won't make them stop beating each other up. ADDED IN EDIT: Those problems run deeper than the school simply not having enough money.
- maxklein 16y agoPerhaps the kids should be swapped out for more obedient kids?
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- RiderOfGiraffes 16y agoRight. I've cooled off somewhat, so I'm going to delete my other comments because I feel that they are intemperate and, in some cases inappropriate. I apologise for them. To answer your question ... That's not what I said, and I feel it's a misrepresentation of my position. I was answering the question in this comment: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2211298 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2211298 where the author said: Could you clarify why having more cash will not help? My point was that the socio-economic conditions of some kids being dis-engaged, disinterested and actively disruptive would not be helped by throwing more cash at the school, or at the teachers. Whether you blame the teachers, the kids, their parents, the social circumstances, the gangs, television, or whatever, the situation is that in some classes there is behavior that prevents any kind of learning. That behavior won't be fixed by mending copiers, or providing laptops. That's my answer to the question that was asked. In addition, however, I will say that yes, in some cases I do blame the kids, but in some cases I don't. I don't know that I would be any different given the circumstances that surround them. The challenge is to find a way to give them the skills, tools, abilities and opportunities to go where they can make something of themselves. My wish for every child is that they have the opportunity to be the best they can. Sounds corny, and it's certainly Quixotic, but I put money and time into it. And now I am going away for a while.
- scott_s 16y agoHis concluding sentence implies that he thinks more money is part of the answer, but not the whole answer.
- martincmartin 16y agoSounds like school vouchers would do better. No?
- watchandwait 16y agoThese schools are awash in money. Per capita student spending has gone through the roof the last three decades, and NY spends as much as any place in America. http://empirezone.blogs.nytimes.com/2007/05/24/the-highest-per-pupil-spending-in-the-us/ http://empirezone.blogs.nytimes.com/2007/05/24/the-highest-p... The unions and bureaucracy suck the system dry. That's why less-funded private schools in NYC consistently outperform public schools. Every single rotten thing is the result of either dysfunctional culture or dysfunctional management structure/incentives.
- InclinedPlane 16y agoYup, as with most instances of mass starvation in the late 20th century the problem is never lack of food, it's mismanagement.
- nhebb 16y agoThere's a pretty good piece in City Journal about how some schools are awash in money, but that isn't the core problem . teen pregnancy is: http://www.city-journal.org/2011/21_1_teen-pregnancy.html http://www.city-journal.org/2011/21_1_teen-pregnancy.html The rate of single parent families has risen dramatically in the past few decades, with the rates climbing even higher in urban areas. Raising kids takes time and money - two things you have much less of when you are a single parent. There has been a lot written about this subject, but it's politically taboo and not much will (or can) be done about it.
- Anechoic 16y ago> That's why less-funded private schools in NYC consistently outperform public schools. The "less-funded private schools" are also allowed to choose the cream-of-the-crop, are not required to enroll child with special needs and can jettison problem students at the drop of a hat. As I wrote earlier, if the problem was strictly "unions" you would expect states without collective bargaining agreements to outperform states with those agreements and they don't: http://shankerblog.org/?p=895 http://shankerblog.org/?p=895