7 ms·
> I like Amazon's recommendation engine, but I'm surprised when I check out suggested future releases and get no more than a single page. I'm interested in a wh
by gwern 16y ago
> I like Amazon's recommendation engine, but I'm surprised when I check out suggested future releases and get no more than a single page. I'm interested in a whole lot of things, and I think my purchase history and such would support that, but for whatever reason Amazon sometimes doesn't show me very much.
My theory is that this is evidence that the engine is using http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Collaborative_filtering http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Collaborative_filtering - the way I think of it is as a giant Venn diagram. At the beginning, I fit in almost every one of the little circles because the service is so ignorant about me. It will recommend me stuff from just about any overlapping circle. But as I select and anti-select items, more circles become invalid, and I slowly narrow myself down into a cramped little circle of just the items I've decided about, until finally no one else's selections overlap with my own and the service can't find anyone similar to steal recommendations from to give to me.
- jamesbritt 16y agoGood observation. Also a bit sad, if true, as it suggests that anyone outside the mainstream will get fewer recommendations. Of course, it's tricky, and I appreciate an approach that takes into account that not everyone who likes Foo will like the same things; other likes and dislikes give important context. But I'd prefer a somewhat larger, if less precise, set of suggestions over a small set.