2 ms·
that's why I side with the Sony [...] That's how a capitalist free market works. The free market works such that after a product is sold, the seller has no rig
by marshray 16y ago
that's why I side with the Sony [...] That's how a capitalist free market works.
The free market works such that after a product is sold, the seller has no rights it any more. They cannot remotely disable features after the sale. They cannot dictate what you can and can't do with it.
The PS3 hackers didn't "open source" any of Sony's code, that's ridiculous. Their goal is to bypass it and load their own. They reverse engineered it for the purpose of enabling compatibility with other stuff and extending. This has a long tradition in the US.
Perhaps you're old enough to remember when Ma Bell claimed it was illegal for anyone to plug in a home answering machine or for anyone else to make compatible telephones?
After 70 years of R&D you had a choice of three kinds of home phones in one of several colors. The only leg that argument had to stand on was that they were a regulated monopoly and as such deserved protection from the free market. The US decided we'd had enough of that approach and told them otherwise.
I don't even have space to list the choices in communications we gained since that that monopoly was broken up. That's how a free market works dude.
- jeromec 16y agoThe free market works such that after a product is sold, the seller has no rights it any more. They cannot remotely disable features after the sale. I agree 100% (unless such special use terms were part of the sale upfront, see pay tv channels). They cannot dictate what you can and can't do with it. Not for personal use, no, and I should insist not. However, if I sell you a book I wrote, while you're quite free to read or burn your copy of it, I don't want you to scan copies and widely distribute it. The PS3 hackers didn't "open source" any of Sony's code, that's ridiculous. Their goal is to bypass it and load their own. They reverse engineered it for the purpose of enabling compatibility with other stuff and extending. This has a long tradition in the US. If they only took actions for their own personal use I have absolutely no objection. Quite the contrary, I'd encourage it. I can't say I remember the telephone incident, but I agree with your sentiments on that entirely.
- russell 16y agoIt was the Carterphone decision in 1968. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carterfone http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carterfone The Carterphone was a device that allowed amateur radio to connect to the phone system, albeit with a Bell interface device. Another decision in 1978 removed the requirement for the Bell interface. Before this decision you had to rent modems from ma bell or use acoustic modems. Those were the good old days when you dialed up your computer and stuffed the phone handset into the side of your teletype for an astounding 300 baud connection. Fortunately teletypes were so clunky that you couldnt type any faster than that any way.