3 ms·
Given the performance of Google's auto-captioning, I suspect developing worthwhile auto-captioning is pretty difficult; according to [1] the better Youtube chan
by michaelt 7y ago
Given the performance of Google's auto-captioning, I suspect developing worthwhile auto-captioning is pretty difficult; according to [1] the better Youtube channels use gig economy captioning at $1 per minute.
Of course, there would be some scope for efficiency - no need to pay for captioning when the performers aren't speaking!
[1] https://www.wired.com/story/problem-with-youtubes-terrible-closed-craptions/ https://www.wired.com/story/problem-with-youtubes-terrible-c...
- lowdose 7y agoWhile Youtube auto captioning has a superior performance compared to Google Translate output. In youtube translations there is much more language specific nuance. In many European languages a more formal word for the English word "you" exists, in German it is "Sie", French "Vous". Correct interpretations of these nuances are applied by Youtube, Google however translates "you" by default to the most formal option. So to me $1 dollar per minute sounds like an awesome deal because there is not much to adjust. Out of curiosity, can you link to such a gig company?
- uncle_j 7y agoYoutube auto captioning doesn't work for British Accents especially anything Northern English, Scottish or Welsh. The same with any voice control, It doesn't work with my west country accent.
- qwerty456127 7y ago> In many European languages a more formal word for the English word "you" exists, in German it is "Sie", French "Vous". Using formally-incorrect word for You is probably the least serious mistranslation possible. Everybody is going to get the meaning and, as long as they know that's a translation, nobody but a complete retard would complain about that seriously.
- lowdose 7y agoI just mentioned in this respect Youtube performance is better than Google. I do think the formal nuance is outdated and should be deleted. We know from Korean pilots that after switching to English as default in the cockpit a significant decrease in crash rates was accomplished. This was 100% ascribed to the lack of formal nuance in English. I have a hunch a lot of European languages are handicapped by similar conditions.
- qwerty456127 7y agoFun fact is English actually deprecated the informal (singular) "thou" instead of the tradition to address people you respect in plural.
- ghaff 7y agoI don’t know if it’s a gig company necessarily. As I understand it they don’t use Amazon Turk anymore but I use CastingWords and have been very happy with them. I think they’re just English though.
- michaelt 7y ago> Out of curiosity, can you link to such a gig company? The one mentioned in the article is https://www.rev.com/ https://www.rev.com/
- ghaff 7y agoThat’s what I do for podcasts. Machine translation is getting pretty good but, for publishing an interview transcript, I’d still be spending a lot of my time to clean it up. For a human transcript it’s maybe 15 minutes work.
- ghaff 7y agoPresumably an option would be, if they want to self-host, is to run the audio through an ML service and post the link. Doesn’t really work for user-uploaded video as well. But it would be pretty easy to build into a content upload pipeline at low cost. As others say it’s not perfect but I have to believe it would be good enough and probably isn’t a bad idea in any case.