3 ms·
Organ partials aren't perfectly periodic. There's some chaotic pressure variation around the lip, and the pipe also distorts mechanically with pressure variatio
by TheOtherHobbes 7y ago
Organ partials aren't perfectly periodic. There's some chaotic pressure variation around the lip, and the pipe also distorts mechanically with pressure variations along the various possible modes - much more than a stiffer instrument played with lower pressure, like a flute. So not only are the partials subtly inharmonic in various ways, they also have different attack envelopes at the start of a note, and the air pressure from the bellows/pump may also vary over time as notes/ranks are played.
This is one of those common situations in music where a trivial model is too superficial to capture the defining subtleties of a system. The richness of a full pipe organ is a combination of subtle effects within each pipe, combined with subtle variations within each rank, combined with the not-so-subtle effect of combining multiple ranks, combined with the acoustic environment of the hall, which doesn't just add a generic stereo reverb, but also supports standing waves at some of the lower bass notes.
A filtered chiptune wave really isn't a very good approximation.