3 ms·
An organ pipe, when played on low to moderate pressure and allowed to reach a steady state, generates a pure harmonic tone. There is only a single audible oscil
by mrob 7y ago
An organ pipe, when played on low to moderate pressure and allowed to reach a steady state, generates a pure harmonic tone. There is only a single audible oscillator (either the column of air in the flue pipe, or the acoustically coupled system of the beating reed and the column of air in a reed pipe), and this oscillator is periodic, so all partials are exact integer multiple of the fundamental.
This is not true of all instruments. A string oscillates both by tension along the string and by bending across the string. The bending component becomes especially important with thick strings, so a bass guitar produces noticeably inharmonic sounds. This can make the sound more complex and interesting, but it can also result in "muddy" sounding chords. A hammered string, such as used in a piano, works the same way. Pianos traditionally compensate for this by using "stretched" tuning, i.e. going up an octave is slightly more than a doubling of a frequency. This helps the harmonics of the chords line up with the slightly sharp partials of the inharmonic tone.
Another way to avoid the inharmonicity is with bowed strings. Here the slip-stick motion of the bow resets the motion of the string every cycle, like hard sync in a chiptune. The bowed string in steady state is purely harmonic.
Tuned percussion instruments have even more oscillators interacting. A marimba bar twists and stretches along many different axis, resulting in a complex inharmonic tone. A skilled tuner can adjust the shape of the bar to bring many of the partials close to integer ratios. The same is true of bells.
See https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Inharmonicity https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Inharmonicity
A pipe organ can have a noisy "chiff" at the start of the note, but whether or not this is audible depends on how the pipes are voiced. It has been considered desirable or an unacceptable fault according to the fashions of the time, so there is nothing wrong with omitting it.
It is not practical to control how far the pallets are opened by partially depressing the keys. In a mechanical action organ it takes significant force to overcome the initial air pressure, which generally makes the pallet spring all the way open. Pneumatic and electric actions don't even theoretically allow partial opening. I am not aware of any organ composition which calls for partial opening.
IMO a filtered chiptune wave, with good quality reverb, makes a excellent organ-like tone.
- TheOtherHobbes 7y agoOrgan partials aren't perfectly periodic. There's some chaotic pressure variation around the lip, and the pipe also distorts mechanically with pressure variations along the various possible modes - much more than a stiffer instrument played with lower pressure, like a flute. So not only are the partials subtly inharmonic in various ways, they also have different attack envelopes at the start of a note, and the air pressure from the bellows/pump may also vary over time as notes/ranks are played. This is one of those common situations in music where a trivial model is too superficial to capture the defining subtleties of a system. The richness of a full pipe organ is a combination of subtle effects within each pipe, combined with subtle variations within each rank, combined with the not-so-subtle effect of combining multiple ranks, combined with the acoustic environment of the hall, which doesn't just add a generic stereo reverb, but also supports standing waves at some of the lower bass notes. A filtered chiptune wave really isn't a very good approximation.
- magicalhippo 7y agoYour post reminded me of this video[1], where the guy plays this giant double bass. You can clearly see how the low frequency oscillation of the string forms as he drags the bow across it. [1]: https://youtu.be/3K3VdVbBOxw?t=388 https://youtu.be/3K3VdVbBOxw?t=388
- gshubert17 7y agoThis reminds me of a chapter "The Organ Makers' Shop" in Matthew Crawford's book _The World Beyond Your Head_. The author spent a lot of time with organ makers Taylor and Boody (Staunton, Virginia) in 2007 and 2008 and his descriptions are rich and interesting.