4 ms·
The thread is already filled with the usual "CEOs only call for regulation when they're ahead" posts. I find this to be such a shallow generic libertarian take
by Barrin92 7y ago
The thread is already filled with the usual "CEOs only call for regulation when they're ahead" posts.
I find this to be such a shallow generic libertarian take on tech. Not only does this always seem to come from people who eat up everything tech executives say on every other topic except regulation, it also totally treats Pichai's arguments in bad faith.
Here's another take. Pichai is just a smart guy who is genuinely worried about the abuse of the technology because there is indeed a lot of state actors or other potential to abuse the technology in privacy damaging ways. If you want to scare Google with regulation try anti-trust, not AI and privacy security.
Nobody is competing with Google or the large players on AI anyway, regulation or not. Their advantage is in data, scale and talent. If anything higher privacy standards might create ecosystems of privacy focussed companies in the space.
- jariel 7y ago"Pichai is just a smart guy who is genuinely worried about" It's the CEO of one of the world's larges companies talking. What he says publicly is fundamentally corporate communications and 'part of this job', it's nary impossible to separate out his 'personal view'. "Nobody is competing with Google or the large players on AI anyway, regulation or not." - this is quite upside down, there are tons of smaller AI players competing indirectly with Google. When Google 'open sources' some research, it may benefit them and others, but put a slew of others out of business. It's not goodwill, it's mostly for profit. By wiping out the encroachment of adjacent industries entirely they keep their moat, and the surpluses in their core line of business. This is the logic behind open sourcing Android. If you think they're just 'nice' consider why they don't open source the rest of their software.
- _bxg1 7y agoI'm someone who generally thinks we need much more tolerance for regulation in the States, and even I'm not buying Pichai's stance. CEOs of publicly-traded corporations do not act in good faith towards anyone but shareholders. We can debate whether or not they're morally obligated to (I would say yes), but realistically, they do not. The only reason a hired CEO would push for regulation of his own industry besides wanting to stifle competition, would be if current (or upcoming) regulation was unpredictable and he wanted to reduce risk by getting a clear-cut answer. You maybe could make that argument around something like privacy where there's a mounting wave of public pressure. But at least right now, AI is in no such situation.
- Barrin92 7y agoGoogle probably loses out a good amount of bucks due to their stances on defence work. I don't see how this can be attributed to some sort of cynical corporate play, it's simply company culture. Likewise, I don't see how a lot of these companies calling for facial recognition bans can be considered to be in their interest. When the government looks for large infrastructure those companies are the only real players. Remove all regulation, and the government still not hand their data to some sort of garage startup. CEOs of large companies are totally able to act in good faith towards people other than their shareholders. Of course, often they do not, but they certainly can. The arguments around caution and privacy of citizens are sound and reasonable. Everyone can make them. There is no reason to not listen to Pichai just because he runs a business.