3 ms·
> Yet, in an era in which fact-checking has become a national pastime, podcasts have largely evaded serious scrutiny. I think one of the reasons for this is th
by gnicholas 7y ago
> Yet, in an era in which fact-checking has become a national pastime, podcasts have largely evaded serious scrutiny.
I think one of the reasons for this is that there is more friction involved in quoting and disproving a claim in a podcast, versus a blog post or news article. You can’t just copy/past and then link to a source that disproves the claim. You have to rewind, transcribe, include a time stamp, and the new source.
This is certainly not the only reason, but as someone who has listened to podcasts and wanted to correct things via twitter or wherever, this has been an important factor for me.
- jccalhoun 7y agoThis might be one of the reasons why I tend to dislike scripted non-fiction podcasts. When I read non-fiction I am a habitual checker of sources. I want to make sure they actually say what the book I'm reading claims they say. That is a lot harder to do with podcasts.
- awb 7y ago> When I read non-fiction I am a habitual checker of sources That's amazing. How often do you find errors and how egregious are they? People cherry pick facts all the time, so I tend to take any citation with a grain of salt.
- jccalhoun 7y agoWhen I was in grad school doing research for my dissertation there was more than one time when I came across a great quote I wanted to use, read the original source, and found it didn't have that quote at all. At least twice I searched for that "quote" online and eventually found that it started life as a paraphrase of the work in question and the book I first read and taken it as a quote. In more casual reading I will more often find someone making a grand claim with only a citation to support it and I want to make sure that the source actually makes a solid argument for that grand claim. So it might be something like "Charles Babbage predicted the internet" and I need to go see what he actually predicted to see what he actually said/wrote (I just made that example up)
- Wowfunhappy 7y agoOne thing that NPR usually (always?) does, which I quite appreciate, is put out transcripts of their episodes. If the podcast is scripted/produced to any significant degree (ie, it's not just a discussion show), I can't think of many reasons why everyone shouldn't be doing this.
- mirimir 7y agoYes! Maybe I'd follow some, if they did. I mean, I don't commute. And it's hard for me to focus simultaneously on what I'm doing and what I'm hearing. I don't even like music with lyrics, unless I'm just chilling. And generally, I find it much harder to follow audio. Reading anything, I'm always jumping around. I scan, and then loop back for details. And not always linearly. But doing that with audio is nontrivial.