4 ms·
Things like this lead me to wonder: how is the experience of trauma affected by cultural practice, myth, ideas, etc. Certainly similar experiences can lead to d
by colechristensen 7y ago
Things like this lead me to wonder: how is the experience of trauma affected by cultural practice, myth, ideas, etc. Certainly similar experiences can lead to different outcomes from ignorance to indifference to trauma in different individuals. Why is that and how could traumatic outcomes be changed? Should they be?
It is a touchy subject because it is easy to interpret as invalidating deep personal feelings, but that isn't the goal at all.
Would, say, young people drafted for war from a modern Spartan society experience the same trauma in war as young people drafted from Berkeley? I am sure that individuals from both sides would have experiences across the spectrum, but would the distribution differ?
I do think that modern Western society goes to extremes to prevent children from experiencing or even knowing about the harsh realities of the world and it's not hard to conclude that when the sheltered youth are dumped into reality (considerably more) serious mental illness follows as the world they were prepared for and the world they live in are very different.
- marktangotango 7y agoWhy would anyone wonder that? Just because the majority perspective is of a life a relative plenty, open-ness, and stability of the rule of law, they might perceive people in general to be sheltered or soft, but that’s certainly not true for many. There are plenty of stories about famine, starvation, neglect, and abuse in many parts of the world (and at home!) to dissuade anyone of this entire notion. Question for any of us who romanticize more austere, brutish times is; why? There are many ways to test ourselves, doing so helps with perspective I believe.
- RHSeeger 7y agoWhy wouldn't they? 1. Thing X happens in our world 2. We shelter people / avoid discussing the realities of thing X 3. People that experience thing X are severely, negatively emotionally impacted Wondering if talking about thing X more openly in our society would help avoid/temper/mitigate that impact seems... like a reasonable line of thought to me.
- humanrebar 7y ago> Would, say, young people drafted for war from a modern Spartan society experience the same trauma in war as young people drafted from Berkeley? Most of Sparta was slaves, and the upper class participated in murder of slaves as a rite of passage, so I doubt there is a lot in common.
- ajross 7y agoAlso, ancient Spartans were hardly immune to PTSD. They were just much less likely to be treated for the symptoms in any real way (or, frankly, to survive the events that cause them). There's really no good evidence that PTSD is a modern thing at all. What's really, and ironically, happening here is that "Sparta" is a movie utopia us pathetic moderners have invented to mask our anxieties behind an ideal about Real Men who spent their lives kicking Persians into giant pits instead of dealing with credit overdrafts (and, occasionally, PTSD).
- GloriousKoji 7y agoIn the scope of miscarriages I think culture definitely makes it more traumatic. Miscarriages are not uncommon but some how many cultures tend to stigmatize it and then blame the woman, as if it was something in her control. The constant reminder, blaming or just having that social pressure looming over of not having a successful child birth has to be some sort of trauma magnitude multiplier.
- dsfyu404ed 7y ago>how is the experience of trauma affected by cultural practice Trauma is immensely affected by cultural practice. 120yr ago many infants died from childbirth complications and of those that didn't a large fraction dropped dead by age 5. It wasn't unheard of for parents to give subsequent kids the names of older deceased siblings. This was all considered normal and for the most part nobody got too bent out of shape over it.
- colechristensen 7y ago>for the most part nobody got too bent out of shape over it Some definitely did, stories can easily be found which confirms that those experiences where some times traumatic. The question is about how it was different for an individual or a population in much different circumstances.
- allovernow 7y ago>how is the experience of trauma affected by cultural practice, myth, ideas, etc You're certainly onto something. In other cultures, schizophrenia has historically been viewed through a mythological lense as a possession by or visitation from benevolent spirits. In stark contrast to Western manifestation of the disorder, voices and hallucinations take on a much more benign form[1]. People by and large can be rather content in a wide range of environments, even if by comparison to other environments they seem quite harsh oppressive. Normalcy is very much a social construct - even ideas about something as universal as pain can vary widely, to the effect that some cultures are more likely than others to seek out physical and mental trials which others may consider traumatic. Indeed, to some degree we have a loosly related term for a phenomenon where those who suffer abuse have no desire to leave their abusers: Stockholm Syndrome. Except imagine instead of being raised by a tormentor with whom you come to sympathize, you develop in a society where certain "abuses" are wholly normalized - if everyone around you shares the experience openly, particularly if justified with myth or alleged purpose, it becomes much less likely to cause trauma. Consider the abhorrent practice of, say, genital mutilation, or general oppressiveness common in certain parts of the middle East or Africa - while I do not condone such practices, I suspect that the majority of those who experience them do not suffer from anything like PTSD, as they are common and effectively normalized. I'd be very interested to see a study on the subject. 1. https://blogs.commons.georgetown.edu/journal-of-health-sciences/issues-2/vol-6-no-2-july-2012/cross-cultural-variance-of-schizophrenia-in-symptoms-diagnosis-and-treatment/ https://blogs.commons.georgetown.edu/journal-of-health-scien...