2 ms·
Sure, they could self-finance repairs. But how do you get from here to there, and is there the promised land you think it is? You can't just take the houses a
by AnimalMuppet 7y ago
Sure, they could self-finance repairs. But how do you get from here to there, and is there the promised land you think it is?
You can't just take the houses away from landlords and rip up all the mortgages - not without destroying the economy. For example, there's a lot of peoples' pensions that are invested in mortgage-backed securities. Sure, it would be nice not to have a mortgage - but maybe not at the price of also not having a pension.
So, how do we get to this place of no landlords and no mortgages without blowing up large chunks of the economy? By the government buying all the mortgages and all the landlord-owned property. That's... rather a large amount of money. Where's the government going to get it? Either from taxes, or from just creating it. That would be quite a bit in taxes, which is kind of zero-sum (and if you think that they're just going to take the taxes from other people, it very rarely works that way). And creating the money would be inflationary, which causes its own kind of damage.
And, would this be the promised land? It would be a land where nobody built new houses ever again, or else a land where the government kept spending money to buy new houses. In one case you'd see the supply of houses age and deteriorate over time. In the other case, you'd see the decision of how many new houses to make being made politically, rather than by the market. That usually works out sub-optimally.
So be careful what you wish for. Not having to pay rent sounds nice. But your solution may be worse than the current problem.