3 ms·
You’re assuming that getting a clear face view would result in: 1. Identifying the person 2. The authorities finding this person 3. The arrest of this person
by teddyh 7y ago
You’re assuming that getting a clear face view would result in:
1. Identifying the person
2. The authorities finding this person
3. The arrest of this person
4. A conviction of this person
and possibly also
5. You getting your things back.
In my cynical experience, every single one of these five assumptions is extremely unlikely to actually happen. Note that each one of them depends on all the previous ones.
- bborud 7y agoThat's not what OP asked and probably not the answer he/she really wants to read. This being hacker news I had hoped the top comment would be something that actually might help someone who wants to create better stills from video. I see this on a lot of forums: people not answering the question but feeling that they just have to give their piece of advice that OP is having the wrong problem. Stop it. It isn't helpful. Especially to others who look for answeers to the same question (but perhaps for entirely different reasons).
- teddyh 7y agoThere are already tons of answers here in the comments about solving the problem as stated. I’m just pointing out that solving that exact problem might not be what they actually wanted. Realizing this before you go down a long, arduous, and possibly expensive, path to solve the problem, is valuable. See: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/XY_problem https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/XY_problem
- stronglikedan 7y agoBut this isn't just a Q&A forum. It's also a discussion forum, and OP's post contributed to the discussion. It's good info, and can save the poster a lot of time, headache, and expectation.
- bborud 7y agoThe OP didn’t ask for legal or procedural advice. The question was a rather straight forward technical one. However, it came with context, which was a mistake because it drew focus away from the actual question.
- theincredulousk 7y agoIt's mostly true, but your cynical experience is probably also anecdotal, unless you are in law enforcement dealing with these cases daily. It's also defeatist not to "stick up" for yourself when you've been done wrong, which consequently only serves to embolden the wrong-doer. In fact I watched these two videos on Ring, since by insane coincidence this happened in a neighborhood less than 3 miles away. Someone there had already recognized seeing the person sitting outside a nearby Starbucks. Facial recognition, image search, and the internet has come a long way. It shouldn't be long or far-fetched that local law enforcement can start leveraging these tools to pursue more of these cases. For all the fear-mongering, and true ethical issues, of facial-recognition and surveillance, this is a situation where it can actually pay dividends. (and no they'll probably never get their stuff back, but that is what insurance is for. Hopefully it was nothing sentimental or otherwise irreplaceable and truly just "stuff")
- teddyh 7y agoI agree that everyone should feel some obligation to do their civic duty to report and pursue criminals. I’m just saying, do it because it’s the right thing to do, but don’t actually expect any of it to have any practical effect for you, personally. It might happen, as in your anecdote, but I’m saying that it’s very unlikely. Coincidentally, do you know if that person in your story was, after being spotted, subsequently identified, apprehended, arrested, and convicted? Posting to HN about wanting to digitally enhance surveillance video indicates, at least to me, someone expecting some practical result (which is unlikely), not someone simply doing what can reasonably be done for the sake of society.