4 ms·
> enough discretionary expenditure to be considered “middle class” I don’t think money makes you ‘middle class’. You can be a millionaire but working class, or
by chrisseaton 7y ago
> enough discretionary expenditure to be considered “middle class”
I don’t think money makes you ‘middle class’. You can be a millionaire but working class, or destitute but upper class. Class is about things like background, education, tastes, social status and connections. Not cash.
- quindecagon 7y agoPerhaps you would prefer the term "middle income." I think your conception of the term class and the one used in the article are different. By substituting the term "middle class" for "middle income"this issue is sidestepped.
- esotericn 7y agoThis is only true in one direction. You can be wealthy and working class, sure. But the converse is simply impractical. How many upper class individuals are there living in a rotting house share, on benefits, hitting up the food bank? There's a minimum amount of capital required to be able to meaningfully participate in social activities at different levels. That might not mean fantastic wealth but neither does it mean working in the corner shop (unless by choice).
- chrisseaton 7y agoIf you’re born a baronet, go to Eton, take a commission in the Guards, but end your days alone and penniless in a care home then I think you’re still upper class until the day you die. Likewise I could win the lottery tomorrow but I’d never have the background and connections to become upper class.
- esotericn 7y agoHmm, yeah, you're right there (on both examples). I'm still not so sure though. That's something of a special case, the extreme upper end and also at the end of one's life. It feels like you at least need to at _some_ point have the wealth if not necessarily personally (e.g. whilst growing up).
- ryanmercer 7y ago> on benefits, hitting up the food bank? While you can't be sure of their net worth (current or planned), It's not uncommon to see people in /r/leanfire and /r/financialindependence/ talking about how to keep their income below poverty thresholds to qualify for medicare and other government assistance when they decide to retire with some occasionally chiming in that they are doing that exact thing successfully right now. Fortunately some of these programs also look at your investment and bank accounts to prevent people from doing just this.
- mnemonicsloth 7y agoBack when most wealth was inherited (before 1800 say), upper class families used to practice primogeniture, or giving all the money to the oldest son. If they didn't do that, then the kids in the nth generation would get something like a 1/2^n share. In that case, nobody in the family would have enough money to support a presence at court to lobby for the family's interests, and eventually their claim to noble status would die out. Upper class parents concluded that having some wealthy sons was better than having no wealthy sons eventually. The dynamic of the younger, educated, connected but poor son of a noble family is pretty important in history, even if it isn't interesting to us in the egalitarian West. But such people did sometimes succeed in making themselves rich, and probably more often succeeded in impoverishing themselves further. A lot of them ended up as bandits.
- OJFord 7y agoIt does to Americans though, or at least to some and is the definition being used here.
- dahart 7y ago> Class is about things like background, education, tastes, social status and connections. Not cash. This is an archaic definition that doesn’t really even work anymore (see tech billionaires, for example). In economic discussions, class means ‘socioeconomic status’ which is defined as net financial worth, e.g., income plus savings. It is not just common for class to be defined by cash, I guess it’s probably the most commonly used definition now. In any case, it’s very common and perfectly acceptable to draw the line between classes using income brackets.
- Spritle 7y agoAlthough this definition is not in use as much as it used to be for those in the American middle and lower classes, it is very very much alive and well in the American upper classes. If you don't live in the "good" neighborhoods and you went to public school and you've never been to Europe then you're going to get looked down upon. Yes, there are people that made their money in one generation. These are the Nouveau riche. They may find that they are not as accepted as the guy that drives an old Mercedes and wears second-hand clothes. It's about how your were raised. And accessorizing. :-)
- dahart 7y agoIn that sense, the archaic definition of upper class exists and is being as a mechanism for social prejudice and exclusivity; as a way to keep new money out. I don’t disagree it exists, but I’d argue it’s socially harmful and that we should actively strive to replace that definition with the one that’s actually measurable, rather than arguing against socio-economic status as a synonym for social class like the GP’s comment did.
- bloak 7y ago> Class is about things like background, education, tastes, social status and connections. Not cash. I agree. But not everyone would. I think England's class system has broken down in the sense that it is no longer the case that everyone agrees what the classes are and who belongs to them. There are people who perceive class in terms of level of education, and there are people who perceive class in terms of money, and probably there are still a few people who perceive class in terms of ancestry and heraldry and Burke's Peerage.