3 ms·
When reading articles like these I am mostly surprised, because my experience with FOSS has been largely different. I maintain a few semi-popular libraries like
by stavros 7y ago
When reading articles like these I am mostly surprised, because my experience with FOSS has been largely different. I maintain a few semi-popular libraries like shortuuid and catt, but users have always been helpful and courteous, the pull requests have always had the best interests of the library in mind and the users were open to feedback, and the worst I've gotten was users politely asking for support with their particular setup, to which I politely reply that I unfortunately don't have enough time to debug things outside the scope of the code and that's that.
Has anyone else had this experience? Maybe the trouble comes with libraries as popular as ripgrep, or maybe it comes more often to a specific type of person. I'm generally not very patient, so I'd expect to have much more trouble than other maintainers, but I'm also just not negatively affected by bugs and PRs at all. People filing them have taken their time to do it, which means my code is important enough to them to spend time improving it, and bugs happen, so I take bug reports as compliments rather than as personal failures.
Hopefully someone else has the same experience as me, and maybe we can figure out how to generalize that experience for others.
- burntsushi 7y agoYeah, not everyone is going to have the same experience. And I'm sure it's at least partially related to your user base. For example, most of the things I build are _mostly_ consumed by other programmers. But what if it was consumed by mostly non-technical users? I'm sure anyone could guess how that might impact your own experience with your users. (I do have some projects, like nflgame, that were mostly targeted at folks who were beginning coders or even sometimes folks who couldn't code at all. The experience was quite different, but overall still positive.) I think the other thing I'd like to re-iterate is that the vast majority of my interaction with others in FOSS is either neutral or positive. This is kind of what I meant by the negativity overshadowing the positive and how, at least for me personally, the negativity sticks in my memories more than anything else.
- StavrosK 7y ago> I think the other thing I'd like to re-iterate is that the vast majority of my interaction with others in FOSS is either neutral or positive. I think this is the issue. I get maybe a few issues a month, so I don't get enough volume to have very negative interactions. By the way, thanks for ripgrep, it's one of the most-used and most useful tools in my command line.
- einpoklum 7y agoI maintain a TB extension for removing duplicate messages. It has ~70K users or so (of course, people use it rarely, not regularly). I always get new bugs or low-score reviews claiming "the extension didn't detect my dupes!" - when actually the messages are not quite dupes, just very similar, and I have to err on the side of caution when suggesting messages to delete. So I have to keep explaining this to people who are telling me that my extension sucks or doesn't work. But - with some other FOSS libraries it's been mostly positive.