3 ms·
That strawberries are not true berries becomes fairly obvious once you learn that tomatoes are berries. All berries seem to have fairly watery flesh surrounded
by mcv 7y ago
That strawberries are not true berries becomes fairly obvious once you learn that tomatoes are berries. All berries seem to have fairly watery flesh surrounded by a thin but tough skin. Tomatoes have both, strawberries have neither. Raspberries superficially look like a collection of tiny berries from this perspective. Bananas have a skin, but it's not thin, and their flesh is not watery.
That's just my layman's analysis, though. It's suited me well for many years, but if now eggplants and peppers are also berries, I'm starting to wonder whether the word berry even means anything.
- lordgrenville 7y agoThere's a deeper point here about how scientific taxonomies differ from folk taxonomies. Scientists might decide to classify something based on its genetic makeup or microscopic structure, whereas laypeople will classify based on macroscopic appearance or use or taste. Neither one of these is closer to the absolute truth, they are both just heuristics useful in different contexts. Scott Alexander has a somewhat related post: https://slatestarcodex.com/2014/11/21/the-categories-were-made-for-man-not-man-for-the-categories/ https://slatestarcodex.com/2014/11/21/the-categories-were-ma...
- ragazzina 7y ago>All berries seem to have fairly watery flesh surrounded by a thin but tough skin. The point of the article was that bananas are berries though, and your definition doesn't really describe bananas (maybe kiwis).
- mcv 7y agoI know. I'm just sharing my definition, which is completely subjective and holds no authorative value. It works for me, though. Kiwis are a bit hairy to be berries, but they feel closer to berries to be than bananas.