3 ms·
As someone from the “global south.” When I see people use the term, I play a game where I check to see if they are a westerner with a degree in something useles
by rayiner 7y ago
As someone from the “global south.” When I see people use the term, I play a game where I check to see if they are a westerner with a degree in something useless. Invariably, they are. The author of your article, for example, is an anthropologist from London. In the actual “global south” (like Bangladesh, where I am from), your mother would be ashamed if you got a degree in anthropology, instead of engineering, business, computer science, etc. You know, things that allow you to participate in global capitalism. People in the actual global south tend to be supportive of capitalism, because it’s literally transforming their lives: https://www.forbes.com/sites/alyssaayres/2014/10/28/bangladesh-capitalist-haven/ https://www.forbes.com/sites/alyssaayres/2014/10/28/banglade...
My family left Bangladesh in 1989. In that time, purchasing power adjusted per capita GDP has tripled. Infant mortality has been cut in half, and life expectancy is up by more than a decade. Malnutrition is down by more than half. The brain drain is even slowing down. While my family left, many bright young people are staying to work in burgeoning industries. It’s a goddamn miracle. Unsurprisingly Bangladeshis are among the most supportive of free markets of any country in the world. This is true all over Asia, where there is a combination of people who have developed the institutions to support capitalism, but haven’t yet become jaded by all the wealth capitalism has brought them.
People who major in degrees like anthropology and use terms like “the global south” are dangerous. They’re selling snake oil. They’re anti-vaxxers or the people telling you to go on a fruit diet to treat your cancer. The gist of their pitch is this: “Ignore how all of the developed world got wealthy. Also, ignore how South Korea, Japan, Taiwan, Singapore, etc. got rich. Also, ignore how Malaysia, Thailand, etc. are well on their way to getting rich. Capitalists don’t have any answers for you. We, the anthropologists, political scientists, etc., we have the answers.”
Complaining about “enclosure” of farming land? Really? They want us to go back to communal farming? Using “indigenous technology?” It’s like they fetishize our poverty. How about, instead, we do the same thing Europeans and Americans did to get rich? Empirical science, rule of law, stable government, property and economic rights, individual freedom, and free markets.
(Regarding the claim that poverty has actually gone up if you use higher income thresholds. Your article doesn’t cite sources. But World Bank data shows that even at higher extreme poverty thresholds, rates have declined dramatically: https://openknowledge.worldbank.org/bitstream/handle/10986/30418/9781464813306_Ch03.pdf https://openknowledge.worldbank.org/bitstream/handle/10986/3....
Using $5.50 as the benchmark, it’s declined by 21 points since 1990. In South Asia (which excludes China), its down by 14 points. In Latin America it has been cut in half. The only place that it’s not moved is sub Saharan Africa, and that’s because those societies lack the societal institutions to support democracy and capitalism. Which is unfortunate, but anthropologists aren’t going to be able to do anything to fix that.)
- candiodari 7y agoI don't think you fully understand the position of those "anthropology majors" (I disagree with the name a bit: the vast majority of them have never put in any effort, not in work, not in study, and don't have any degree at all). Communal farming is how people in the west pretend they're rich. If you're poor you're eating things like burgers, white bread, very processed food. Eating apples, gluten free, "natural" food, etc is expensive, and it's mostly considered good because it is expensive (when you look at actual medical data, it's much higher risk than processed food). Communal farms have sprung up as a way for people to unwind after work, holiday places for the very rich. “indigenous technology” is what they played with as kids, on holidays with their parents. It's not something that is used in the West, except for entertainment or marketing purposes, or in musea or events. > but anthropologists aren’t going to be able to do anything to fix that. Yeah, for them, dictatorships and heavy handed government violence is good. After all, it's how they want to treat their opponents, who keep insisting on realism. Actual, workable plans. And it's good ! Just look at how quickly China moved off plastic bags: https://www.treehugger.com/corporate-responsibility/chinas-ban-kept-100-billion-plastic-bags-out-of-the-trash.html https://www.treehugger.com/corporate-responsibility/chinas-b... > They’re selling snake oil. Snake oil that is "really important" and, most importantly, it doesn't require any skill whatsoever beyond protesting. Nothing beyond shouting "No" really loudly, which is the second word a newborn baby learns (after "gimme") and frankly you're an idiot if you haven't learned to do this by 1 year of age.