4 ms·
What do you think God is? Evangelical atheists want him to be a straw man poking his head of the clouds Monty-Python-style; but what if God is just a metaphor
by dasil003 16y ago
What do you think God is? Evangelical atheists want him to be a straw man poking his head of the clouds Monty-Python-style; but what if God is just a metaphor for everything greater than the reality we are capable of understanding in our tiny carbon-based brains? Do you really want to believe that the only things that matter in life are those that can be hypothesized, measured, and analyzed with physical instruments?
If the answer is yes, that's fine, but remember that you are taking that assertion on faith. There is simply no evidence one way or the other about what lies outside the bounds of human knowledge.
- stopmi 16y ago"that which can be asserted without proof can be dismissed without proof" and why give weight to the ramblings of the religious but not to all schizophrenics? shouldn't we give both views equal respect without calling to reason? edit: referring to the "difficult to tell the difference between real and unreal experiences/delusions/hallucinations" symptoms when i said schizophrenics
- baddox 16y agoSchizophrenia isn't what you think it is.
- doorhammer 16y agoIf a schizophrenic developed an elegant solution for highly efficient, commercially viable solar-panels, I'd probably listen intently to his views on semiconductors, while politely opting out of the dissertation on talking toast.
- stopmi 16y agoheh.. or recruiting people to jump into the lion's den at the zoo to give it a hug? edited my parent comment to make it clearer
- dasil003 16y ago> "that which can be asserted without proof can be dismissed without proof" Exactly! And vice versa! Who said anything about "giving weight" to "ramblings"? You are fixated on everything being about truth and facts and who's right, but that's not what I'm talking about. Maybe you don't want anything bigger than observable facts and theories based thereupon in your life, but I hope when your parents say they love you you don't tell yourself that it's simply endorphins firing in their brains.
- stopmi 16y ago"You are fixated on everything being about truth and facts and who's right" would you rather i countered an argument with untruths and lies? what i'm trying to say is, if you are willing to give credibility to any assertion which is without proof, then you have to give an equal amount to credibility to _all_ assertions without proof i.e, all religions equally, fairies, leprechauns, elfs, russel's teapot, a furry-god, Elvis still alive, alien-invasions and abductions, etc.. and problems arise then, if you give credibility to _all_ religions, there will be contradictions - they have different creation stories and timelines - multiple 'unique' prophets - multiple 'chosen' tribe/people etc..
- mckoss 16y agoEvidence for the way the world works is all around us. Holding onto faith in creationism and other religion-based myths is holding many people back from understanding what real evidence we have about the world. If you want to go to the extreme of arguing that using evidence as a justification for believing (or not believing) in something is an act of faith, then I don't think we can have a reasonable argument about anything.
- nostrademons 16y agoLarry Wall said in the interview that he considers evolution to be fact. And yes, the idea of using evidence as justification is itself an act of faith. This is not that extreme a position - take a look at The Structure of Scientific Revolutions for evidence (ironic, isn't it?) of that. At some point, you have to take some basic principles as given. Otherwise, you end up with circular reasoning. The decision to slice the world into atheist vs. religious is itself a rather arbitrary one, just like how it's weird (when you think about it) that skin color has become the source of 500 years of hate, while nobody blinks twice (ha, ha) about someone's eye color. Why not slice the world into open-minded vs. close-minded people? There are open-minded theists (Wall is one of them) and close-minded atheists, just like there are close-minded theists and open-minded atheists.
- mckoss 16y agoHis statements about having to integrate contradictions in his thinking are very interesting. I wouldn't have the patience for it. Why not just discard the single belief (held only on faith), and get rid of the contradictions in one fell swoop? I can only believe that those positions hold such a cherished part of his personally identity, that he is unable, or unwilling to do it.
- chromatic 16y agoWhy not just discard the single belief (held only on faith), and get rid of the contradictions in one fell swoop? For one thing, even the best philosophers and epistemologists have been unable to do so for millennia, all swell foops aside.
- prodigal_erik 16y agoIt's not just a metaphor. Christians self-report believing much more specific things about God's opinions and demands. As for me, I don't "want to believe" things. What I want is for the model in my head to match reality. To have reasons other than apparent truth for believing anything is to invite self-deception. It's hard enough to winnow out the nonsense our culture has saddled us with, without actually rooting for some of it.