4 ms·
It's a hard problem because what is relevant is inherently subjective and context specific and only a minority of users uses the advanced search functionality s
by jillesvangurp 7y ago
It's a hard problem because what is relevant is inherently subjective and context specific and only a minority of users uses the advanced search functionality so it is also not a big priority to solve it. Both Google and Duck Duck Go optimize for the simple use case where there's a bit of user context and some short query that the user typed. That's what needs to work well. For that Google is still pretty good. I try duck duck go once in a while but it's just not good enough for me right now. And of course when Google fails me, that's probably also a hard case for Duck Duck Go.
The other problem is that websites provide very inconsistent meta-data, and worse, are actively trying to game the system by abusing that metadata. So, things like timestamps are not standardized at all (well, a little bit via things like microformats). So recency of data is important as one of many relevance signals but not necessarily super accurate. And given that it's a relevance signal, you have people doing SEO trying to game that as well.
Anyway, Hacker News could also do with some search improvements to its ranking. It always pulls up some ancient article as the most relevant thing as opposed as the article from last week that I remembered and wanted to find back. I consult people on building search engines with Elasticsearch, so I have some idea what I'm talking about. It seems the ranking is basically "sort by points". Probably not that hard to fix that with some additional ranking signals. I just searched for "search" expecting to find this article near the top 5 (because it is recent and has search in the title). Nope; not a thing.
- zozbot234 7y agoHacker News doesn't even have search at the moment. It just redirects you to some crappy external site.
- detaro 7y agoIt giving the YC startup running the search backend some visibility doesn't mean it somehow "doesn't even have seaarch".
- jillesvangurp 7y agoExactly, there's a search box on the web site. How it's implemented is an implementation detail. Given that it happens to be something by a company (Algolia) selling this as a SAAS solution, I don't think this is a great advertisement for them either.
- Kiro 7y agoAlgolia is a YC company.