4 ms·
Do not feed the trolls. The net number of people adopting C++ in any unit time dwarfs by orders of magnitude the number adopting Rust; and the number already u
by ncmncm 7y ago
Do not feed the trolls.
The net number of people adopting C++ in any unit time dwarfs by orders of magnitude the number adopting Rust; and the number already using C++ exceeds that of Rust by many more. That will remain true for a long time. As a consequence, any improvement to C++, either core language or library, has overwhelmingly larger lasting real-world benefit than any corresponding feature in Rust.
Rust pursues benefits by making a class of low-level errors hard to express, at some cost to expressiveness, and at quite substantial cost to adopters who must learn to work around the limitation (which they do). Against such cost it provides some convenient new control flow features, and leaves behind many C and C++ misfeatures that C++ cannot.
C++, instead, pursues benefits by making the language increasingly able to capture semantics in libraries, and thereby deliver thoroughly optimized and tested semantics to users without compromise. The result is that C++ users, by using such libraries, are able to code at a level high above that where the bugs prevented by Rust would manifest, and write less code that could harbor bugs of any kind, overall.
It is not clear whether adoption of high-level coding practices by coders using or switching to C++ will produce more benefit than those adopting Rust, and coding without access to such libraries. I have placed my own bet, and we will see.
But we can say with certainty that every coder who switches to modern, safe C++ from C or C-like C++, or to Rust, is a net win for humanity. And, if Rust in the end fails to grow out of its boutique niche (which is still absolutely possible), everyone later leaving Rust for C++ will bring to it high expectations that will incrementally raise the quality level of new C++ code.
Bad-mouthing of C++ by Rust fans may feel good, but it causes a net harm to humanity by the degree to which it reduces the number of coders who switch to modern C++ from C. The number of C coders who switch to Rust, instead, is far, far too small to compensate for such harm.
So the only defensible, responsible behavior is for C++ and Rust users to promote C++ and Rust (not necessarily in that order) and concentrate on getting coders off C.
- LessDmesg 7y agoYou have some strange ideas about why people use C instead of C++ these days. People continue using C not because C++ lacks coroutines or something else (a strange argument for C which has almost no features to speak of), and not because they hate safety. No, people use C dor the sake of portability, for the sake of embedded systems, and for the sake of utter simplicity where that is required. Weaning them off C to C++ is impossible because C++ already doesn't fit their requirements. In fact, Rust is better suited to embedded devices than C++, so there's no real need to proselytize C++ to C programmers. Or to anyone, I would argue, because C++ is a terrible language nearly impossible to write safe software in, as well as an ergonomical, developmental and compilational pain in the ass. In fact, I believe that in terms of developer time wasted as well user frustration, C++ is the most harmful language in the history of humanity. Someday I'll put together a page listing the dozens of C++'s design daults. Here's just a single article demonstrating how incompatible with simplicity and correctness C++ is: http://www.icu-project.org/docs/papers/cpp_report/the_anatomy_of_the_assignment_operator.html http://www.icu-project.org/docs/papers/cpp_report/the_anatom...
- EliRivers 7y agoIn my experience, the majority of C that is used is actually by people who think they're working in C++, because they were taught to use manual memory management, raw pointers and other such C-like constructs. Some keywords about classes were thrown in towards the end of "C++ 101" or whatever they learned from, and away they go, writing C with classes like the last 30 something years never happened.
- jefftk 7y agoThat's still C++, just not modern C++.
- EliRivers 7y agoTechnically, in that the C++ spec allows it, yes, it's C++. However, I find such definitions to be of little practical use, although frequently in the workplace I sit and wait while someone satisfies their need to carefully divide the world up into precise, clear, exacting and useless definitions before we can get on with doing something useful - the industry just seems to attract that; often they don't care about trashing all those lines immediately afterwards, so long as everyone acknowledged the lines. That said, the discussion about how many layers there are in a model of networking and what they're named rendered some people unable to do anything for the rest of the day. Colloquially and practically, I might suggest that it demonstrates that the programmer may be dangerously thinking in C with little lumps of data as their classes. The programmer is thinking and coding in C, with some classes, that they then feed to a C++ compiler. People were doing it like that back in the nineties, when what we think of as "modern C++" didn't exist.
- rossmohax 7y agoAFAIK this very problem is addressed with introduction of move semantic and the goodness, which comes with it, such as unique_ptr instead of raw pointers. With that default move assignment operator does the right thing by default. So C++ langauge development actually improves simplicity and correcness as least for this particular example.
- 7y ago
- tsimionescu 7y agoI'm not sure modern C++ has proven to be safer than C (old C++ most certainly has not). Also, I'm not as sure as you that there is an overwhelming number of people adopting modern C++, given the slow speed at which I've seen at least my company being able to move to C++11 and then C++14. The reality is that C++ is still an extremely unsafe language, where any slight deviation from strict discipline (discipline that itself has only really been ergonomical since C++14 or so) will lead to memory corruption errors. Even with modern C++ features you can get memory corruption: null references, references to moved objects, no way to signal errors from destructors, and there is still no good way to check whether an operation on ints will overflow. Moreover, the insistence on optimizing around undefined behavior, specific to C and C++ I believe, coupled with large reliance on undefined behavior in the standard, leaves C++ in a very poor position as far as guarantees of safety are concerned. In general, the responsible thing if we want a more secure world would be to discourage the use of manual memory management as much as possible, whether it be in C, C++ or Fortran. That does include trying to get people to use smart pointers if they absolutely have to use C++, but it should also include getting people to use other languages if at all possible (Java, C# or Go would be the more mature ones for large business).
- inDigiNeous 7y agoYou're saying that switching to "safe" modern C++ is just something you could do at a whim. Learning how to write safe C++ is a hell of a task to undergo, and still you are at the mercy of your program crashing even though you have taken careful approach to memory management etc. Modern C++ is just not a safe language to program with. It is very easy to produce errors that result in segmentation faults, and it takes great care to produce code that works properly even with shared_ptrs and unique_ptrs and so on. But you are correct that adoption of C++ is higher than Rust, and will continue to be so until some mission critical framework or for example game engine starts to support Rust in as a first citizen language. Until then, we have modern C++, with all it's quirks and difficulties and lost developer time in figuring out where the hell was that dangling pointer or why the heck was an object not freed correctly, or why did the array access or vector access go off by some value. Not saying C++ isn't good, it is, but a lot of time is wasted figuring with C++ currently when a lot safer alternative could be used. Unfortunately that is not very realistic in many scenarios yet, although I carefully evalulated Rust also for my current project, the requirement of supporting a C++ game engine just outweighs easily the hassle of having to figure out bridges and bindings and such.
- ncmncm 7y agoWriting safe modern C++ is much easier, and much less work than the old ways. So it is easy to switch, and easy to tell if you are Doing It Right: if it's not clean, safe, and easy, there is a better way.