4 ms·
Fighting against your own government isn’t like fighting against a foreign power. You have the advantage of asymmetric warfare, and also the advantage that the
by rayiner 7y ago
Fighting against your own government isn’t like fighting against a foreign power. You have the advantage of asymmetric warfare, and also the advantage that the military will not follow orders to just “steamroll right in through” citizens. Egypt has F-16s, but that didn’t stop the government from getting overthrown when the military decided to stay neutral. Libya had advanced Soviet weaponry, but Gaddafi was overthrown and killed by rebel forces.
Unless you’re willing to level your own country (which for practical reasons even
tyrannical dictators are not), fighting armed citizens is nothing like fighting a foreign war. (Also, the track record for advanced nations losing wars in places like Afghanistan with vastly inferior weapons is significant). The Syrian civil war also started with a civil uprising, with armed civilian guerrillas fighting government security forces. Again, there were defections when soldiers refused to fire on citizens, and that led to establishment of the Free Syrian Army, comprised of defectors from Assad’s regime.
Here is how it played out when Bangladesh declared independence from Pakistan. The Pakistani military was armed with modern US made aircraft and weapons, launched Operation Searchlight, which killed at least 300,000 Bangladeshis. Civilians took control of arms depots and started shooting back. That precipitated Bangali units of Pakistan’s military to mutiny and start fighting for independence. Military assistance from India helped win the war, but that started many months later. Without being able to take control of those arms depots to begin with, Bangladesh never would have been able to start the war that led to independence. (The American Revolution, by the way, played out more or less the same way. Guerrilla attacks at first, seizing weapons and supplies, creating a more formal militia, and then getting assistance of a foreign power.)
It’s not some crazy NRA fantasy. We have numerous examples of despotic regimes with modern weapons and aircraft being overthrown in civilian uprisings. I come from a country that exists because of such events. The Second Amendment is there to preserve that option. Had Bangladeshis been armed like NRA wingnuts in 1970, hundreds of thousands of innocent people might have been alive today, hundreds of thousands of Bangladeshi women may not have gotten raped by the Pakistani military, etc.
- jacobwilliamroy 7y agoThe firearms are not enough. The Mukti Bahini were heavily assisted by members of India's Research and Analysis Wing. India provided weapons, ammunition, logistical support, and many of the refugees who volunteered were recruited and trained on Indian soil. Months before the revolution had even started Indian spies fabricated evidence linking Pakistan to the 1971 Indian Airlines hijacking, which India used to justify a ban of all Pakistani flights across its airspace, preventing Pakistani carriers from resupplying East Pakistan by air. Indira Ghandi herself was basically a foreign ambassador for Bangladesh, traveling the world not only to drum up political support for the cause, but to also to justify India's impending war with Pakistan to the international community. India and the USSR went to bat for Bangladesh at the UNSC, and India was the first U.N. state to give Bangladesh diplomatic recognition. Bangladesh also had many allies among warsaw pact countries such as the GDR (East Germany), Bulgaria, Czechoslovakia, Hungary, Romania and the Soviet Union, during the war. All of whom supported the cause in some way, be that medical services for wounded soldiers, diplomatic/economic support, scholarships for Bangladeshi students or other things. That's what separates Bangladeshi force from 99% of NRA wingnuts: training, organization, support from foreign allies. Because of these differences, I do not expect a similar international response to occur in the event of a civil war in the U.S. And I think such is ultimately what will make or break an insurgency.
- rayiner 7y agoIndia undoubtedly assisted. But Operation Searchlight began in March 1971. The first civilian response began March through May. Members of the Pakistan military defected in April. The order for the RAW to assist the guerrillas was given in late April. The Warsaw Pact countries declared their support in August. Direct military intervention from India ended the war in December. Without armed resistance from the people, there would have been nothing to support.