4 ms·
Whether China's yuan should be freely convertible to other currencies is something the PRC has struggled with for years. A freely convertible yuan would increas
by Animats 7y ago
Whether China's yuan should be freely convertible to other currencies is something the PRC has struggled with for years. A freely convertible yuan would increase China's influence on the world financial system, but it would also increase the influence of the world financial system on China. And it would require much easing, if not elimination, of China's exchange controls.
A decade ago, a freely convertible yuan was seen as likely. But China has backed off from that. Xi Jinping's "China 2025" is about autarky - reducing China's dependency on the rest of the world.
So, the yuan as a world currency isn't really happening yet.
Euros, though...
- redis_mlc 7y agoEuros are, literally, a joke. A currency without an army is nothing. You can pretend whatever exchange rate you want between the Euro and the USD, but the USD is the real currency.
- HenryBemis 7y agoYes because USA Vs the world will have USA as a winner (if this is what you imply) which is 5yo thinking. EU although it still going through some growing pains, appears to be far more mature than today's USA, which is burning bridges and building walls (I mean figuratively). If/as the planet continues to decrease its dependency to USD then the might will decrease further with it. USA has the No1 debt on this planet. I don't see any other countries of that size going bust and needing to print new money every other year because they cannot afford to run their states. I am using this childish and realistic example so you include that in your thought process. As for the army, EU is in the process of considering/designing an EU army, since the "US hegemony" seems to be in deep .... with USA's latest leadership. And thank you for speeding up this process.
- tpxl 7y ago>A currency without an army is nothing. The Swiss beg to differ.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- radiorental 7y agoMilitary service is mandatory in Switzerland
- austinjp 7y ago> A currency without an army is nothing. Can you expand on this? What's the financial function of an army? What's the military function of a currency? I can imagine what you might say but I'd like to read it to know for sure.
- anticodon 7y agoSo far US invaded or staged a coup in every country that had audacity to refuse using US dollar. That is one of the most important functions of US military power. Also, countries with US military bases aren't really sovereign. They can't for example refuse to invest significant portion of their GDP in US treasuries.
- sudoaza 7y agoTrue, one of the last things Saddam did was sell oil in different currencies to the us dollar
- kmlx 7y agoagree with your comment except the last semi-sentance. the euro has other issues, including dismal growth rates of the Euro area, an ineffective ECB, multiple diverging national financial strategies, and very long term, the massive ageing and shrinking of the european population. i don't see the Euro as anything but a very short term panacea. it needs to solve its structural issues before it can become more than it is.
- rusttoxic 7y agoPopulation is the reason why euros are importing uneducated hoodlums though not sure population alone would fix Euro's problems
- MR4D 7y agoThe yuan won’t be freely convertible because that would open the floodgates to capital flight from China. As long as that possibility exists, free convertibility will not.
- cinquemb 7y agoYeah, on top of the issues of infrastructure around payments/settlements/collateral management/kyc laws that often go ignored in these discussions as well as the high correlation of lowering (euro)dollar usage globally with lower global growth rates… ideally you'd have higher growth rates with lower (euro)dollar usage if there was any serious alternative. Fundamentally speaking, I think non CB backed cryptos (combined with hedging tools via futures/options/swaps/ndfs/etc) have a better chance because they can be used to lower the costs intl of payments/settlements/etc, esp in these times when the trust in central banking becomes more and more contested. But I only see this happening slowly until there's a catalyst to push this to the next level.
- erikpukinskis 7y agoI would expect cryptocurrency to ascend in a series of hops, “chaos is a ladder” style. Every time a central bank somewhere takes home their toys, crypto will click forward.
- cinquemb 7y agoYeah, that's probably a better way to put what I think I wanted to get at.
- meerita 7y agoActually they're flooding with yuans. 2018 and 19 they opened the gates to avoid the economy crash.
- MR4D 7y agoFlooding their market. Converting to dollars or other currencies is still very limited. [1] and [2] 1 - https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2019-12-12/after-a-decade-of-drama-china-s-yuan-reform-has-far-way-to-go https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2019-12-12/after-a-d... 2 - https://www.scmp.com/economy/china-economy/article/3012312/chinas-capital-outflow-controls-have-gone-extreme-former https://www.scmp.com/economy/china-economy/article/3012312/c...
- roenxi 7y agoGiven the extreme questionability of all currencies for anyone who wants to, y'know, hold on to currencies; why not just do without? There isn't any theoretical reason a world currency is needed. Instead of pricing Yuan and Euros in terms of some third currency people could price them in terms of each other and cut out the middle man. Speaking as an Australian; about 3-4% of our trading by value is with the United States. I shouldn't ever have to see a value priced in US dollars. I really don't care what the price of anything is in US dollars. The only reason the US dollar impacts me as far as I can tell is because it is embedded deeply into SWIFT and is required internationally to trade in oil. Important in practice but not in theory.
- cdiddy2 7y ago7 days late here, but its not an accident that things are priced in USD in the middle of transactions, and its not purely because the US wanted it that way. Imagine if you as an Australian wanted to trade with venezuela. You go and make a deal selling something for some bolivars. But by the time you get the money the bolivars are not the worth the same in AUD as when you started the deal. Now you might say that the Venezualans should just hold some AUD in order to trade with australia. but they want to trade with the rest of the world as well so they would have to hold some of everyones currencies based on how much they plan to trade with them. This is infeasible so instead they use USD as the middle man to trade with everyone else, and everyone else agrees that they will accept USD for their trades. this removes the currency risk between countries assuming the USD is liquid and remains somewhat steady, which it has for the purpose of world trade.