4 ms·
Lisp aside, I found something tragic, or at least a terribly tragic phase to their career: They stayed at JPL because it was a more meaningful place to work and
by ineedasername 7y ago
Lisp aside, I found something tragic, or at least a terribly tragic phase to their career: They stayed at JPL because it was a more meaningful place to work and abhorred the possibility of Java drudgery. Fine, good.
Then they went to Google, as it appeared different from the corporate bureaucratic programmer = widget approach, only to be charged with implementing a massive Java project. So, irony.
But the real tragedy was that it was all for Ad Tech. Presumably tired of the same JPL work, they not only end up using a hated tool, but also working on something that seems on the opposite end of the "meaningful work" spectrum. Adding to the tragedy, they could have taken any number of development jobs that happened to use Java and yet pushed the needle forward on meaningful work.
I really regret the last 20 years of the best & brightest being drawn into the modern equivalent of Mad Men advertising firms. I do however take a fair bit of solace in the fact that these massive companies and massive systems have resulted, if only as a side effect, in excellent technology that allows corralling and orchestrating massive amounts computational power in a way I thought a bit too "utopian" when "utility computing" was being bandied about in the 90's. Just kind of wish some other monetization model had emerged. Freemium looked promising for a while, but it turned out there was still an infinity of user acquisition friction in between "free" and "extremely cheap". Oh well. I still have hope for the next decade or so.
- xixixao 7y agoI guess it’s a suicide to point this out on HN, but not everyone thinks Ad Tech is the opposite of meaningful work. I think it’s a very “limited imagination” point of view if you a) can’t think of anything less meaningful that people spend their time on, b) can’t think of any upside that Ad Tech brings. I’m happy to elaborate, having worked on ad tech for over 3 years, in case this comment doesn’t get downvoted into oblivion.
- GoOnThenDoTell 7y agoI honestly couldn’t think of a positive thing for adtech. Do share
- theaustinseven 7y agoHow do you think all of the startups on here really achieve the "viral" growth they all talk about? Heavily targeted ads have allowed niche businesses to get off the ground and become profitable in a way that was not previously possible. Agreed there are problems, and agreed they don't allow much(if any) real control over the targeting from the target's side of things, but to say that don't do any real good is unimaginative as the previous comment said.
- scroblart 7y agoIt is doing the great and worthy work of connecting consumers with the products they desire.
- na85 7y agoThat's neither great nor worthy. A truly good product sells itself. All advertising is just manipulation.
- OmarShehata 7y ago"A truly great product sells itself" is one of the most persistent myths engineers believe. I don't understand how people can still believe this when it's so obviously false. It's a nice story, that if you make something great you'll get what you deserve. That sounds fair, but there's no reason to believe the market works this way. A "truly great product" that no one (or not enough people) know about will go out of business and disappear. Good advertising is just communication.
- mindcrime 7y agoA truly good product sells itself. That's completely absurd. How can a product "sell itself" if nobody knows it exists, or knows how great it is? How do they find out those things? Well, in part, by advertising. I heartily agree that some advertising is manipulative and anti-social... but I can't buy this "all advertising is just manipulation" stuff.
- _bxg1 7y ago
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- jsd1982 7y agoPlease elaborate and also please always feel free to do so!
- kortilla 7y agoThinking of things less meaningful doesn’t suddenly make something meaningful in the general sense. Both can still be pretty meaningless when it comes to advancing society long term. Optimal auction algorithms for ad placement can be interesting technical work and there can be some interesting economics work in there for price discovery, but in the grand scheme of things it’s not very meaningful to the broader world. You won’t be getting a Nobel prize and your kids and grandkids won’t even be impressed with what you do. Side note: don’t talk about downvotes coming for your post. It’s a sure way to ensure it and it’s boring.
- ineedasername 7y agoYou present a false dichotomy to represent my view as one end of "ad tech bad" with the other "ad tech good" or something along those lines. However when contrasted with helping explore the solar system and helping to build an ad-bidding platform, I think there's a clear winner in which pushed humanity forward as a civilization. You also attribute to me beliefs I don't state. Lamenting the tremendous talent that has gone into ad tech instead of what I would consider more worth while endeavors doesn't mean I don't value it at all. Ad tech has facilitated robust sets of nominally "free" tools that certainly have some value. My opinion of the field, however, is that the "hard" problems it contains are neither as hard nor as meaningful as other areas that have attracted less talent. It seems you'd like to attribute to me opinions that are "black or white", but I'm afraid my views on things are not so simple, and as such not so easy a subject for simple rebuttal.
- xixixao 7y agoI’m glad that this your view, thanks for the clarification. You did literally write that ad tech is on the “opposite end of meaningful work spectrum”, and we both agree that space exploration is certainly on the positive end of it. This literally mirrors the definition of black and white (ends of the color spectrum). I am sure you are right in that there areas that would deserve more talent given their impact. Care to elaborate which ones stand out in your mind? (Besides space exploration?)
- WWLink 7y agoUgh. I understand exactly what you're talking about here. I work in SoCal for a smaller aerospace firm. According to glassdoor, the pay is pretty decent (a little above average for a software engineer out here), but it really pales in comparison to the numbers I hear people mention when talking about "FAANG" lol. The cost of living is not less. If you want a 30 minute commute, be prepared to pay through the arse for a 50 year old house in need of serious repairs. The traffic is an atrocity. I grew up in the Bay Area and never in my life have I seen anything like this. The benefits can vary from garbage to decent. Where I work, there's free lunch, free dinner, and free (really good) health insurance. OTOH, some other companies have "coffee clubs" and "water clubs" where groups of coworkers donate money to have a monthly supply of water/coffee in their office space. Oh yeah, and no matter what, if you say you work on space stuff, everyone assumes you work at spacex or nasa. There are no exceptions. lol. Edit: I realize I probably forgot the upshot. Yeah, this kinda work is pretty darn cool! I also really enjoy doing it, or I'd go work on something else.
- mst 7y agoComplete tangent but ... you grew up in the bay area, currently live in socal ... but you spelled it "pay through the arse" like I (a .uk resident) would. Care to explain why? No big deal, but my linguistic curiosity is piqued.
- xvedejas 7y agoI see "arse" used on occasion here in the US as a way to make "ass" sound milder. It's like using "darn" instead of "damn", munging the pronunciation. In either case, the cultural exchange goes both ways.
- hhsuey 7y agoWe say "arse" here to be less crass.
- klipt 7y agoThat's funny, because calling someone an "ass" can be euphemistically explained away as just saying they're a donkey, while "arse" is unambiguously anatomical.
- blahneverdies 7y agoPerhaps they weren't so bright after all.
- ineedasername 7y agoI don't doubt their intelligence or talent in solving problems. But chasing the highest Total Compensation, or glittering silicon jewel, or a comforting workplace that closely resembled the social & work dynamics they'd just graduate from in college... they were comfortable choices to make. Even chasing money losing startups for the first decade of your career always held the prospect of an off-ramp to one of the established players. Chasing work that moves the needle forward on culture, society, and civilization often requires a higher tolerance for risk and discomfort.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]