4 ms·
Genetic engineer here (though I've mostly worked in humans). Cross-kingdom gene transfer has been occurring due to pathogen vectors amongst plants for as long
by alevskaya 7y ago
Genetic engineer here (though I've mostly worked in humans). Cross-kingdom gene transfer has been occurring due to pathogen vectors amongst plants for as long as plants have been around. On a geological time scale the amount of gene-flow is significant, and any tricks that would allow domination and apocalypse would already have come to the fore. Most every change we make to crops weaken them as wild competitors.
If you're looking for Talebian disaster, it has already happened. Seriously: Most of earth's arable land is dominated by a tiny handful of species in the order Poales, with much of the rest dominated by other invasive species brought in for grazing a few animal species. The point of genetic engineering is to help maximize yield and resilience of our intensively worked land so that we have some chance of saving what little is left of the natural world, whatever mistakes we commit now would not be materially worse than what we've already done, and we need every trick in the book to try to preserve what is left.
- aiscapehumanity 7y agoDo you think a better method is combining genetic engineering with vertical farming?
- arrosenberg 7y agoIt's not an either or proposition. We should be using restorative agriculture (and similar practices) in regions where food can be grown outdoors to maximize yields and sink as much carbon and water as possible into the ground. Vertical farming becomes especially useful in areas where growing fresh food is hard, but energy access is abundant. Use GMOs in both cases, though they will be different variants.
- barry-cotter 7y agoVertical farming is only economical with very, very expensive by weight crops. If you’re planning to use artificial light rather than sunlight you’ve got to compete with people growing crops in the open air or in greenhouses where the lighting is free.