5 ms·
> currencies like China's and Russia's might soon be 20% backed by gold. He makes the point that there is no need for 100% backing from gold since a smaller per
by thaumasiotes 7y ago
> currencies like China's and Russia's might soon be 20% backed by gold. He makes the point that there is no need for 100% backing from gold since a smaller percentage would still prevent a country from printing new currency out of thin air.
What is the conceptual difference between a currency that is 100% backed by gold and one that is 20% backed by gold? Or rather, what is the difference between a currency that is 20% backed by gold, and another currency that is (a) 100% backed by gold; and (b) worth five times as much as the first currency?
- abacadaba 7y agoas compared to dollars, of course. (alt s/dollars/bitcoin/)
- thaumasiotes 7y agoI don't understand this. Can you expand on it?
- abacadaba 7y agowhatever they come up with will still be valued in terms of dollars, as dollars are still the fundamental unit of currency inherent to the universe.
- mark_l_watson 7y agoI think that his point is that 100% gold backing would make the price of gold very high, and a partial gold backing would be easier to accomplish with many of the same benefits like better long term stability (if some shorter term pain).
- thaumasiotes 7y agoSo, in these two scenarios: 1. The currency is 100% backed by gold. 2. The currency is 20% backed by gold. How much gold does it take to purchase 200 apples? You are saying that it will take more gold in the second case, right? Why?
- pillpicket 7y agoNo in the first case it might take 1 currency to buy 200 apples. Then in the second case it would take 5 currency to purchase the same 200 apples. 1 gold = 200 apples 1 gold * 1 currency = 200 apples 0.2 gold * 5 = 200 apples
- thaumasiotes 7y agoThat's what I was saying, but mark_l_watson is saying that in case 1 the price of gold is higher, meaning a smaller amount of gold to buy the same number of apples.
- mark_l_watson 7y agoI don’t have Rikard’s book in front of me, but from memory I think he was saying that the price of gold would adjust to $10K/ounce if currency were 20% backed by gold, but the price of gold would have to be much higher than $10K/ounce if currencies were 100% backed by gold. I don’t invest in gold, I have always thought that income property is the best investment for common people like myself. Rikard has a different opinion and thinks people should own gold in their portfolio (like 5% gold). I don’t understand the gold market, while income property is easier to understand.
- jonex 7y agoIn this case I interpret "backed by" as that the central bank will give you the corresponding amount of gold for your currency. But, the opposite would not be true, they won't give you currency for gold alone, you'd have to also provide the same kind of backing as for non gold backed currency. So paid in gold or the currency, you'd get the same number of apples in each case. But if you'd convert the currency to gold via the central bank (rather than on the open market) you'd get 1/5 as many apples in the second case. In normal operations this won't make any difference, no one in their right mind would use the central bank rather than the open market to buy gold. But it means that the central bank can't just print money as they see fit, reducing the risk of runaway inflation. It also acts as insurance in the case of runaway inflation, you'll lose at most 80% of the value.
- topmonk 7y agoThe difference is, when you go to the gold standard, how much gold you acquire to support the currency. After that, they are the same (but keep in mind, the value of a currency is dependent on a lot of factors, and not just the gold that is backing it. Otherwise currencies backed by nothing would all be worth nothing, which we know isn't true).
- thaumasiotes 7y ago> (but keep in mind, the value of a currency is dependent on a lot of factors, and not just the gold that is backing it. Otherwise currencies backed by nothing would all be worth nothing, which we know isn't true). True, but once you've pegged the currency to gold, it can't fluctuate very far from the price of gold. A change in one is necessarily an equal change in the other. Currency that isn't backed by gold is free to fluctuate independently of the gold price, but gold-backed currency isn't. You could have a currency backed by a weighted basket of commodities, but that would be "backed by a weighted basket of commodities", not "backed by gold, but the backing is metaphysically different than you might expect".
- topmonk 7y ago> True, but once you've pegged the currency to gold, it can't fluctuate very far from the price of gold. I think this depends on what your definition of backed means. If you include the government not just buying the currency for a given amount of gold, but also selling the currency for the same amount of gold, I agree. But, otherwise, if the government guarantees it will only buy the currency for gold and not vice versa, then I disagree. For example, I could state tomorrow that I will guarantee to give anyone 1 oz. of gold is they give me $100 trillion in USD, and then technically USD would be backed by gold (by me), but such an offer would have no real effect on the how the market would value USD. I might be wrong about what backed means, but if so, then I also don't understand what is meant by partially backed.