5 ms·
My take on the author's take is that by point 10, he's realized what a muddled and silly thing this is. > So what really failed, maybe, wasn’t iTunes at all…
by CharlesW 7y ago
My take on the author's take is that by point 10, he's realized what a muddled and silly thing this is.
> So what really failed, maybe, wasn’t iTunes at all…
At which point whatever substance he's abused to get that far really kicks in for his final point.
> In 1940, the German critic Walter Benjamin wrote about an angel in a Paul Klee painting. […] It is now clear, 80 years later, that the angel is looking at his phone.
Sheesh.
- bjornlouser 7y ago“It is now clear, 80 years later, that the angel is looking at porn on his phone”
- mnemonicsloth 7y agoWalter Benjamin is the original inspiration for the postmodernists. His writing is nonsensically opaque. If his name appears in an article, it's a good sign that the article is about to go off the rails.
- claudiawerner 7y agoYour comment is wonderfully muddled, since Benjamin was not an original inspiration for so-called postmodernist thinkers at all. Benjamin (and his intellectual companions, Adorno, Marcuse and others) were very much modernists, right before the heyday of the French "postmodernists". One has to wonder how 'opaque' Benjamin is, given that he is one of the most studied critical theorists in philosophy and literature. He must be at least translucent if there are knowledgable people making sense and use of his ideas. Apparently his ideas are sufficiently clear and interesting for an interest on HN[0]. In fact... someone on HN in 2014 claimed that Benjamin was a "postmodernist" too, and they were quickly shut down on that claim[1]. [0] https://hn.algolia.com/?q=walter+benjamin https://hn.algolia.com/?q=walter+benjamin [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8295413 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8295413
- bordercases 7y ago> given that he is one of the most studied critical theorists in philosophy and literature Found your problem.
- claudiawerner 7y agoI'll bite: what problem is that?
- bordercases 7y agoCritical theorists aren't worth studying. They have no consistent norms of evaluating the quality of their work and their primary purpose is to advance literary explorations over calibration to any particular truth of the matter. So saying a critical theorist is well-studied by other critical theorists says very little about the value of their positions to non-literary fields. There may have been a fact of the matter as to whether Walter Benjamin really was an inspiration for post-modernism or if he's merely confined to modernism, but I think a true critical theorist would leave that up to debate.
- coldtea 7y agoThe description of someone who learnt about critical theorists from YouTube videos (and I use the term "learnt" loosely).
- claudiawerner 7y ago>They have no consistent norms of evaluating the quality of their work and their primary purpose is to advance literary explorations over calibration to any particular truth of the matter. This is patently false if you read any critical theory, in which reaching the truth on a matter is taken much more seriously than any literary aim. You can claim that mainstream critical theory didn't or isn't reaching the truth, but it's a wild claim to say it makes no attempt to do so. Read the Wikipedia article if you don't believe me. >So saying a critical theorist is well-studied by other critical theorists Critical theorists are studied and used by philosophers, legal scholars, and sociologists - it's not only critical theorists in some kind of secret club where they all congratulate each other. They are studied in literary fields not because of the literary value of their writing, but because of their criticism and aesthetic positions. >but I think a true critical theorist would leave that up to debate. They wouldn't, because critical theorists can recognize the truth and falsity of claims. Your criticism would be better aimed at the so-called postmodernists (and it'd still be wrong).
- dang 7y ago"Please don't post shallow dismissals, especially of other people's work. A good critical comment teaches us something." https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- saeranv 7y agoI think you missed the point of this article, it's meant to light-hearted, and satirical.
- wutbrodo 7y agoYea, it doesn't even function well as a joke, since it says more about Apple's product development pathologies than the broader culture of digital products.