4 ms·
There's a lot of evidence that the bigger factor is transaction cost. People consume more under all-you-can-eat plans than per-transaction plans (e.g. internet
by gumby 7y ago
There's a lot of evidence that the bigger factor is transaction cost. People consume more under all-you-can-eat plans than per-transaction plans (e.g. internet service) even though the unmetered plans may cost more, simply because they don't want the mental overhead. People will drive out of their way to avoid a tool bridge even if the toll costs less than the cost of operating their vehicle for the other route.
All that billing infrastructure costs money as well. Think of how much of the phone and TV cable networks is consumed by nothing but managing tollbooths?
The post from Stratechery yesterday made this point differently: when credit cards were introduced merchants liked them because they no longer needed the (pre-computerized in those days) infrastructure and headcount of billing customers, checking credit, etc.
- gotdvoted9392 7y agoThis all feels like the usual ignorance of externalities. Which feels like ignorance of information not in front of us. This is Adam Smith’s fear of division of labor taken to extremes making ignorant stupid humans. We’re allowed a tiny little sliver of the information needed to make wise decisions, told to defer to others for everything else. It’s described in a variety of ways going back years. We’re not observing much new from humanities social norms. It’s that more people are able to learn and read about it than before. And our tech is nicer. Politically the world still works in the usual ways though.
- inetknght 7y ago> People will drive out of their way to avoid a tool bridge even if the toll costs less than the cost of operating their vehicle for the other route. It's not just the mental overhead here. I specifically avoid toll roads because I think their concept is fundamentally wrong. I pay taxes to pay for roads and their maintenance. I shouldn't have to pay more taxes ("tolls") to pay to use those roads. If it's a private road then it should be marked as such. The public shouldn't be permitted to drive on private roads marked as if they're a interstate or state highway or anything like that. It's deceptive and profiteering off of what the government already provides: transportation infrastructure. And it absolutely should not be permitted for a private entity to purchase an existing road and turn it into a tollway.
- criddell 7y agoWould you be opposed to making all roads toll roads and no longer pay for them with outside taxes?
- inetknght 7y agoYes. Roads and infrastructure should belong to the people.
- criddell 7y agoThey could still belong to the people. It's just that they are paid for by the people who use them. The more you drive, the more you pay. To a small extent the gasoline tax works like this.
- inetknght 7y agoPoor people cannot afford this. It's the whole reason that taxes were set up for road and infrastructure maintenance: so that everyone can benefit instead of just the wealthy.