2 ms·
That's your opinion but anyway a Leaf will still emit when it's moving. Indirectly with the production of the energy, which can be very low in countries such as
by speedgoose 7y ago
That's your opinion but anyway a Leaf will still emit when it's moving. Indirectly with the production of the energy, which can be very low in countries such as France or Norway, and directly with brakes dust even though the electric regen reduces that a lot, and particles from the tires.
- brianwawok 7y agoTire particles are emissions? When I walk are my shoe particles emissions? My skin shedding?
- hexchain 7y agoElectricity. In some places, electricity is still largely produced in thermal power plants, which do pollute a lot. In France and Norway, I guess most of their electricity is from nuclear and water?
- klyrs 7y agoYes, those are particulate emissions. Your skin biodegrades quite readily so it's not much of an issue. Leather-soled shoes could be a tradeoff that I'm unprepared to compute... but yes even your shoes pollute, if to a lesser degree than a motor vehicle. When it snows, do you notice that slush turns black? Much of that is shredded tires; that ends up polluting our waterways or (hopefully) burdening water purification plants.
- perl4ever 7y agoWhat does this have to do with comparing a Leaf to non-BEVs? Is there some reason why the tires would be significantly more or less polluting?
- klyrs 7y agoIt has everything to do with the "zero emissions" claim, and nothing to do with a comparison.
- perl4ever 7y agoIf nothing has zero emissions, then the phrase "zero emissions" would have no use whatsoever, so applying a context where nothing has zero emissions is internally inconsistent. It can't be a null phrase and not a null phrase at the same time. If something has zero emissions, but it's not a BEV, then maybe you should say what and why the correct definition excludes BEVs.
- speedgoose 7y agoThe "zero emission" label is on the back on the car, maybe they should use something else for their marketing.
- perl4ever 7y agoIf you don't like "zero emissions vehicles", what do you think of: - partial zero emissions vehicles - transitional zero emissions vehicles (plug-in hybrids) - advanced technology partial zero emissions vehicles All of these have tailpipes! To the extent that "zero emissions" does mean "no tailpipe" it's pretty straightforward and reasonable.
- klyrs 7y ago> If nothing has zero emissions, then the phrase "zero emissions" would have no use whatsoever Yes, that's the ideal: don't claim that you've achieved the impossible. I don't want to see folks marketing "perpetual motion" machines for the same reason. For a detailed comparison: https://www.researchgate.net/publication/297889793_Non-exhaust_PM_emissions_from_electric_vehicles https://www.researchgate.net/publication/297889793_Non-exhau... Seems fair to call these vehicles "zero exhaust." Electric rail vehicles have extremely low emissions -- if the rails and wheels are carbon steel without added heavy metals, then the direct emissions are relatively benign. Maglev vehicles are even better -- but even so, there's friction with air, moving parts such as doors and lynch pins. Still not zero.
- perl4ever 7y ago