4 ms·
I think he is the one and only sane C-level person in the industry, after hearing this. People claiming most of AI hype barely know what the "AI" people mentio
by baybal2 7y ago
I think he is the one and only sane C-level person in the industry, after hearing this.
People claiming most of AI hype barely know what the "AI" people mention is.
And people who go as far as drawing rosy pictures of human like general AI being your personal chauffeur are past ridiculous.
The entire idea of human-like general AI for practical applications is like trying to make people using horses for transport in 21st century, by trying to make a horse than if better than a car.
- jasonjei 7y agoI don’t think it’s impossible if certain roads/highways or lanes become marked as autonomous only. Just as pedestrians and bicycles are banned from using high-speed roads, manually-operated cars could be banned from using certain roads/lanes, removing a lot of variables that manually-operated cars bring.
- maxerickson 7y agoThat's level 4, by definition. (full autonomy on some/many roads)
- intended 7y agoDefeating the promise of automated driving, and underscoring the obviousness of its impossibility, since this is roughly as useful as a Tram.
- ubertoop 7y agoHow is the ability to leave at your own time, have your own dedicated cabin, and ability to stop nearly anywhere, even in the same ballpark as a Tram...?
- petermcneeley 7y agoIf you have to restrict to marked highways then you could have had this "self driving" technology in the 80s.
- ubertoop 7y agoI wish governments would consider the death and injury toll of manually driving, and fastlane (pun intended) infrastructure for self driving cars, such as specific roads and lanes.
- tim333 7y agoThe tech is changing so quickly that by the time you built the things they would probably be redundant.
- ehsankia 7y agoIsn't it a little silly to call someone "only sane C-level person" after one comment? Also, while claiming these innovations are only a few years way may be insane, saying they will never happen feels probably just as non-sense. History hasn't been on the side of such absolute claims. It will take time, but Waymo already has working 100% self-driving cars out in the wild. Yes it's in a small area, with perfect weather, and with technicians ready to jump in, but it's still a good start and easily paves the way for it to extend over the next decade or so.
- baybal2 7y agoI do feel like that. From my past few years dealing with automotive clients, I haven't heard of a single company that was not completely obsessed with it. All and every piece of electronics we did in the automotive sector had some lame "AI platform" attached somewhere, for no apparent reason. The most blatant "AI washing" I saw was an "AI power steering" which was a plain PID, inferior on all fronts to purpose made systems already on the market. Second to it was an "AI airbag," which was basically an OpenCV hello world that will trigger the airbag ahead of time. Terribly unreliable, and would've probably killed more people than saved.
- Faark 7y agoYes, it's a hype based buzzword. Just like "cloud" could be found everywhere a few years ago by people trying to profit from said hype. And just like "cloud", usage will start to become somewhat more realistic eventually. But I doubt the industry will look exactly like it did before... just like many of us didn't switch back to local bare metal servers. I totally understand mistrust. Less so if there are somewhat capable alpha products already available with huge economic incentives behind made by somewhat reputable companies. It might not happen in the current hype cycle, then it will be a future one. But I don't ever see self driving cars quietly being deployed. That's just a way to well known game changer hardly anyone will want to sit out.
- hilbertseries 7y agohttps://www.cnet.com/news/alphabet-google-waymo-ceo-john-krafcik-autonomous-cars-wont-ever-be-able-to-drive-in-all-conditions/ https://www.cnet.com/news/alphabet-google-waymo-ceo-john-kra... Waymo ceo made a similar statement.
- jacamera 7y agoYou don't understand. We just need more data. Once we have enough data the AI will be able to model all possible scenarios and make a better decision than a human driver ever could! /s
- celeritascelery 7y agoAgreed. I have running bet with fellow at work who owns a Tesla about when we will have self driving cars. He keeps telling me the AI revolution is just around the corner. Still waiting.
- unkulunkulu 7y agoHe talks about difference between level 4 and level 5 (4 - attainable, 5 - may never happen). This is a strange proposition in my book: level 4 is already good enough to bring a lot of value (taxis in a big city are level 4 afaiu), level 5 - ideal but who cares?
- K0SM0S 7y agoIt's actually debatable that you ever need level 5, because once you reach level 4 it's probably only a matter of time until most road infrastructure is converted for L4 self-driving vehicules (once you can statistically prove a self-driving road kills 1000x less than one with human drivers). Like we never wondered about self-driving trains, essentially. It just became a fact once we could do remotely supervized L4, and that novelty was short-lived too.
- kart23 7y agotaxis in a big city isnt neccessarily level 4. True, theres no person in the drivers seat, but there are still things that restrict the operation of a Level 4 system, while 5 is supposed to go anywhere, anytime. Snow, Rain, Fog, even night could all impede Level 4 systems depending on the implementation's restrictions.
- the-pigeon 7y agoAI and autonomous vehicles don't relate. Driving a vehicle is not an AI problem and none of the serious autonomous vehicle teams are using AI. Unless you are using a super loose definition of AI that includes anything with an if statement.
- Slartie 7y agoYou are wrong. And the "serious autonomous teams" are also wrong in not using AI (which is mostly true AFAIK, as long as we don't call basic image recognition to already be "AI"). But that's just because the AI we currently have - basically idiot-savants made of silicon - is mostly useless to them, since the kind of AI they would need for actual, 100%, no-compromise level 5 self driving capabilities hasn't been invented yet, nor does anyone have a promising idea as to how to invent one. I am pretty sure that the only way to actually reach this goal requires a full-blown AGI. Because what we call "driving" and what is often misunderstood as a rather mundane and repetitive mechanical operation of machinery governed by a few simple ground rules is actually an insanely complex task that requires several higher-level capabilities of the human intelligence: besides pattern recognition, quick evaluations of situations with an unbounded number of variables and application of knowledge and concepts to an unlimited number of ever-new traffic situations it requires foresight, communication (of the difficult nonverbal kind) and sometimes even carefully dosed brazenness - to know when rules should better be ignored or bent instead of followed.