6 ms·
Sadly, a flat per-transaction fee of 30 cents or so associated with credit card payment processing means that fees alone eat up over 10% of a $3 plan. Until pa
by zdragnar 7y ago
Sadly, a flat per-transaction fee of 30 cents or so associated with credit card payment processing means that fees alone eat up over 10% of a $3 plan.
Until payment processing is an inherent feature of the monetary system, rather than through multiple third parties, small transactions like these are just bad for everyone.
- wtracy 7y agoI have a suggestion to solve this issue and the "low-paying customers aren't sticky" issue mentioned in another thread: Only make the really cheap plans available as annual subscriptions. Charging $3/month isn't very viable, but I bet $36/year is. (Assuming that the costs of providing the service itself permit that.)
- zdragnar 7y agoI think that is avoided because an annual-only plan at the bottom tier prevents you from charging monthly at higher tiers, or offering annual discounts. Attempting to do both increases the complexity of your pricing scheme, and that translates to abandoned and lost sales. At least, that was my understanding of the reasoning.
- wtracy 7y agoInteresting. I could see creating a tier chart for the different levels of service with "monthly" and "annual" price columns, where the monthly column is crossed out for certain tiers. But I'm not a marketing person.
- zdragnar 7y agoYeah, I think engineer types tend to underestimate how much our training enables us to quickly reason about, and then simply accept, complexity. Pretty much anything that is remotely considered a barrier to your sign up or checkout process costs you sales; having questions or needing to spend time deciding which position on a chart you want to purchase from is time you are giving people to decide maybe they don't actually want to sign up.
- misnome 7y agoThen the price is $3.30? Presumably they think more people would pay a higher amount than walk away because they don’t offer a lower amount? or that people who want to pay for smaller space are more likely to use it, or become less attached to the account and more likely to be less loyal and shop around, or don’t want to support the increased complexity... Card fees would presumably be more of an issue for flat rate $/gb but I don’t think they they are that zero-margin?
- Finnucane 7y agoIf you are old like me you remember when stores had minimum purchase limits for credit cards, and some places (esp. gas stations) would charge different prices for cash or credit. The credit card issuers have strongarmed the retailers to curb those practices, so the only rational response for a service that would be entirely dependent on them would be to have a minimum for everything.
- senordevnyc 7y agoThis is still very common in NYC. Most small restaurants and retailers here have credit card minimums, typically $5-10.
- bitwize 7y agoI still see minimum credit purchase signs, especially in restaurants, cafés, and the like. Generally, they're small -- like $5 or $10 -- making purchase of all but the most trivial of items exceed the limit, but they're technically there.
- scarface74 7y agoLaws have been passed in some places where the credit card companies are not allowed to ban minimum prices or different prices for cash.
- thaeli 7y agoThis is no longer a violation of the merchant agreement. The card brands used to ban minimums, but now merchants are allowed to require a minimum payment for credit. Too many cash-based businesses who just would not bother with a credit card machine at all if they weren't allowed to stay cash-only for small transactions, and the card brands want to be in as many storefronts as possible.
- antod 7y agoIn NZ, those minimums and surcharges are coming back and relatively common. Retailers are getting vocal about the "evils" of credit cards companies too.
- 7y ago
- hakfoo 7y agoI always wondered why no governments decided to get into the payments ecosystem. If you keep the existing rate structure, payment processing represents a ~3% sales tax that yields a huge margin for all players, a tantalizing revenue stream to nationalize. Id you use the state resources to subsidize the price down to zero, you have a great "pro-business"/"pro-inclusive-economy" plank for political points. Either way, you get a huge amount of data and a massive lever you can use for political ends. Think of the deplatforming debates of a year or two ago, but magnified by "this is basically the only payment platform used in the country."
- clairity 7y agogood idea. i'd go further and advocate a government option for every utility-type service, like banking, internet, healthcare, etc. businesses would be free to compete with these government services, but they'd also provide a competitive anchor to help keep markets efficient.
- mtts 7y agoWe used to have that in the Netherlands. For banking, regular banks refused to service small businesses and lower income private people. The government set up two banks of their own, one for small businesses and one for ordinary people to do things like deposit their paychecks and have simple savings accounts. The latter especially was wildly successful and innovative, with a truly forward thinking IT department (they had online banking over dialup in 1987!) Alas, the 90s hit and these banks, along with the energy companies, the cable companies and the postal company, were privatized. Innovation ground to a halt and service quality plummeted. In the end, they had to be bailed out during the 2008 financial crisis.
- leosarev 7y agoRussian Central Bank (our financial authority) have done exactly that. The so called Faster Payments System (Система Быстрых Платежей), launched last year, offers instant money transfers in Russia for 0.05-6 rubles (≈$0.01-0.1). Your bank can charge you on top of that, but i.e. in my bank it totally free (subsidized by other services). Now (since autumn) they are slowly launching payments system (it's not gained traction yet, but it's just started). Tariff for payment system is 0.4-0.7 for retailers, split between your and retailer's bank. Afaik, China also has something like that for for years. I think that USA don't have something like that because political tradition forbids government to compete with established private services. I have read that Americans have to buy commercial software for filing taxes. :-) In Russia, it would be unbelievable — you just using government provided tax filing software free of charge.
- howling 7y agoA potential way to solve this is randomness. Instead of every customer paying $3 per month, every customer has a 10% chance of paying $30 per month.
- zdragnar 7y agoRandomness that only punishes? So you're essentially saying that typical annual cost is going to be 63 a year, but if you are unlucky it could easily be over 120, and your best case scenario is 36? I have to imagine most people would pass.
- howling 7y agoThe best case scenario to a customer in a year is that he pays exactly 0, which happens with probability (0.9)^12.
- wolco 7y agoDoes that one person return the item and try again for it to be free?
- ken 7y agoSo just make it an annual-only plan. Companies that charge subscriptions vastly prefer annual payments to monthly payments, anyway. It's not just the per-transaction percentage that credit card processors take. Cards get declined (expire, etc), and 1/12th the number of charges means 1/12th the number of potential issues. That's why they offer such great discounts for annual billing. DropBox's cheap plan is $10/month when paid annually, but $12/month if you pay monthly, for example.
- dredmorbius 7y agoDo you really want to have the monetary system (the Fed, the Treasury, the Post Office, ...) to be the payor, aribitor, and recordkeeeper of every transaction you make? There are benefits to cash. And despite the tremendous faults and failures, of a (more-or-less) decentralised payments-processor system. Though one might argue that one in which Visa and Mastercard account for 3/4 of all card-based payments[1], even before accounting for the data "sharing" between payment and credit-scoring entities, fails even harder than even the government-controlled case. ________________________________ Notes: 1. https://wallethub.com/edu/cc/market-share-by-credit-card-network/25531/ https://wallethub.com/edu/cc/market-share-by-credit-card-net...
- zdragnar 7y agoI could have chosen my words and phrasing better; I am most certainly adamantly opposed to doing away with cash. Unfortunately, with the costs of transaction fees being put on merchants, there's essentially no incentive for customers to get anything other than what is commonly accepted, and so no way for any new entrant to the system that uses a different (or no) processing fee structure. The closest thing to new has been Stripe, and that too has essentially the same structure as the rest. It is interesting to me that you mention the Post Office- a government run organization that effectively operates independently and probably has less data on you than your phone company. In fact, I suspect an organization set up in a similar manner probably would have the same level of insight and (in theory, if not practice) the same level of privacy for you as Visa or MasterCard. Then again, if I had a magical fiat wand, I would also allow FedEx and UPS to deliver packages into my mailbox rather than leaving them in the rain and snow, so I can't say that I've worked through all the details of where the right balance between "public good demands a monopoly" and "public control is unwarranted and not likely to be more beneficial".
- dredmorbius 7y agoYeah. The problem's a difficult one. More usually, the answer seems to be a mix of bundling and subscriptions. With technology and all that it entails (protocols, data, interchange, hardware, various forms of IP), that itself is problematic in ways simple print content subscriptions generally weren't.