4 ms·
The Surprising Breadth of Harbingers of Failure (2019)
- peteradio 7y agoLol, wouldn't be surprised to find myself in one of these "loser" zip codes. Wish I could read the whole article rather than just the abstract.
- chronicsunshine 7y agohttps://sci-hub.tw/https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/abs/10.1177/0022243719867935 https://sci-hub.tw/https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/abs/10.1...
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- tonyedgecombe 7y agoI wonder what drives this, is it just poor decision making ability.
- wtracy 7y agoOr it could be people with unusual needs or lifestyles. Someone observing a kosher diet will buy different food from the mainstream. Someone with limited use of their hands will buy kitchen appliances that most people won't need. Incidentally, many "As Seen On TV" products were created for people with disabilities. They get marketed to mainstream audiences when the manufacturer realises that there's not a large enough market of disabled people to sustain the product.
- idclip 7y agoProbably the same thing that makes people more likely to root for underdogs. Avoiding the mainstream, etc. These people arent as broken as this article may make it seem. Its interesting how these zip codes are housing bubble resistant for example! Id wager these people arent trying to get rich, just trying to live a decent life and be nice to each other.
- pjc50 7y agoIt's not the people who fail, but the products. I suspect it's some kind of anti-aura effect; those look like the groups that are less likely to be "influencers". The Apple/Tesla strategy also used by lots of fashion products is to sell at high prices to market segments that the rest of the public identify as "cool".
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- ehmish 7y agoCoefficients of demographic characteristics of "Harbringers of failure" zip codes: Age -.2971 High school -.1710 Home value .2865 Bachelor’s degree .1197 Income .0646 White -.3919 Single family .4047 African American .2232 Multifamily .4132 Asian .3426 Distance -.3740 Hispanic .4854 Comp. distance -.4156 Coupon discount -.2333 Nbr. households .3160 Coupon frequency -.3741 Urban .4190 Unit price paid -.0523 Urban clusters -.1603 Meaning of these variables is here: https://docs.google.com/document/d/1d8O9ja_p08w6cSkOPZ-L1sDZU097AdIkw1qm8wJvoZw/edit?usp=sharing https://docs.google.com/document/d/1d8O9ja_p08w6cSkOPZ-L1sDZ...
- cmroanirgo 7y agoNot only do your numbers not appear in the document you provide, one has to wade through pages and reams of stats ... And your comment still makes no sense to me.
- hnuser123456 7y agopage 7 https://sci-hub.tw/https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/abs/10.1177/0022243719867935 https://sci-hub.tw/https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/abs/10.1... Recall that harbinger zip codes have low average successrates, and so a positive (negative) correlation in Table 3 indi-cates that harbinger zip codes have relatively low (high) valueson that variable.
- ehmish 7y agoEffectively what these mean is that, for example, if your product is popular in places where a lot of people are young white people, in a single family household, in the countryside, without a university degree it is not likely to be successful. If your product is popular in places with a lot of older hispanic people, with a university degree, who live in the city, in an apartment building, it's more likely to be successful
- ehmish 7y agoCan't edit it now, but noticed the negative sign was missing off one of them, "single family" should be a negative value. From the paper: These values effectively state the correlation between the odds of the product succeeding, and people who buy the product having that characteristic. Age Average age of head of household Home Value Estimated home value Income Est. household income in the zip code Single Family % of households in single family homes Multi-family % of households in multi-family homes Distance Distance to nearest MassStore store Comp. Distance Distance to nearest competitors’ store Nbr Households Number of households in the zip code % Urbananized % households classified as “Urbanized” % Urban Clusters % households in “Urban Clusters” High School % of households whose highest educational attainment is graduating high sch Bachelors % of households whose highest educational attainment is a bachelor degree White % of households that are identified as “White” African American % of households that are identified as “African American” Asian % of households that are identified as “Asian” Hispanic % of households that are identified as “Hispanic or Latino (of any race)”
- rossdavidh 7y agoMy people!
- benibela 7y agoI feel like a software harbinger Whenever I decide to use some software, it vanishes in insignificance. QBasic, Delphi, FreePascal/Lazarus, Micrografx Picture Publisher, Conitec 3D Game Studio, Java Applets, Mercurial hosted on SourceForge or Bitbucket, QCodeEdit, XQuery
- jtbayly 7y agoThat's funny. Sad, too. Maybe you are just different enough from others that you pick differently.
- pedalpete 7y agoAnybody else feel like they are on both sides of this? Do these people REALLY only end up supporting the products that end up failing? The first time I tried a 1st gen iPod, I was amazed and had to have it. Then bought a Zune HD when it came out, and kept it long into when everyone else had moved on. Windows Phone, yup, I was a supporter. But was also doing yoga, WHM, intermittent fasting, etc. I was "barefoot" running before Born to Run came out, I rode a single speed mountain bike which never really became a thing. I didn't read the entire report because I don't have an account, but are the people who are supposedly the "Harbingers of Failure" just more likely to be early adopters who are more likely trying new things and therefore they end up liking and supporting things that end up failing?
- HackOfAllTrades 7y agoI started reading this article, then found myself skimming more and more as it became flakier and flakier. Now, because I just skimmed most of it, I may be missing some important points -- but my impression is that the authors are so bound up in the details & statistical tests that they can't see any big picture. For example, in discussing household moves they talk about which zipcodes people choose to live in, as if they had perfect freedom of choice. But I don't see where they account for median income. How are we to know if people in a "harbinger" zipcode can even afford to move to a "Group 1" zipcode? Or if it would be a convenient distance from their employment? I simply can't see putting much or any faith in these "results".