4 ms·
A part of the problem is that so many of the people in news seemingly didn't even pay attention in grade school science classes. I remember one local newsroom'
by stcredzero 16y ago
A part of the problem is that so many of the people in news seemingly didn't even pay attention in grade school science classes. I remember one local newsroom's momentary collective embarrassment when it became obvious that one of their number a) had no concept of how fast orbital velocity is b) apparently had an Aristotelian concept of momentum and c) held the 19th century belief that just going a certain speed could somehow harm or stress the human body.
In the US, a lot of news which has technical content is presented by people who don't understand it.
- ynniv 16y agoIt's only a problem if you want quality news. CBS wants advertising revenue, so they will produce content that attracts viewers who will buy advertised products. What they are currently doing produces their desired output. The only real problem is that this bad news becomes "common knowledge", and it is difficult to separate independently derived common knowledge (probably true, or somehow indicative of innate human behavior) from mass media common knowledge (probably false, and ripe for exploitation by a small number of people).
- stcredzero 16y agoThe only real problem is that this bad news becomes "common knowledge" This is a real pernicious problem. For about a decade, the tech fields as a whole underestimated the performance of JIT VM, overestimated the importance of FLOPS, and failed to consider the cost of I/O. Countless Pointy Haired Bosses made misguided decisions on this basis. Hordes of programmers decided not to seriously consider whole families of languages on this basis as well. Always suspect the "common knowledge." The level of common knowledge is like the level of defensive driving on the freeways. About 1/2 the people out there are below average. (If you know about any subject in depth, take stock of how badly misunderstood it is by the general public. Most likely, it's just as bad everywhere else. Information asymmetry! Now go out and profit!)
- CWuestefeld 16y agoAlways suspect the "common knowledge." Not just this, but if anyone uses "common sense" as an argument, run away in fear. As far as I can tell, "common sense" is just code for one of (A) "I'm too lazy to provide a rational explanation"; (B) "I don't think you're worth explaining to"; (C) "I don't think you're capable of understanding"; or (D) "I don't have a real explanation, but I still need to assert the truth of my claim."
- dennisgorelik 16y agoIs it a good time to buy TM?
- whatusername 16y agoHere's a fun recent one from Australia. http://www.abc.net.au/mediawatch/transcripts/s3132384.htm http://www.abc.net.au/mediawatch/transcripts/s3132384.htm Media Watch is a brilliant show.
- jacques_chester 16y agoI prefer Front Line myself. That Michael Moore fellow (no relation to the documentarist) is very trustworthy.
- techiferous 16y ago"so many of the people in news seemingly didn't even pay attention in grade school science classes." I've noticed this, too. For example, I once read on CNN that a satellite was orbiting "one trillion miles" away from Earth. But even more egregious than that numerical error (which was later corrected) was an article a few years ago on how young people's thumbs are "mutating". Basically, the idea was that people were using their thumbs to type on cell phones. Somehow CNN made a genetics story out of it.
- stcredzero 16y agoMaybe that guy on CNN was paying attention in biology, but he was passing notes to the cute redhead when the teacher was covering Lamarckian evolution right at the moment he explained it was wrong.
- sliverstorm 16y agohad no concept of how fast orbital velocity is Umm... what do you mean by that? I consider myself fairly well versed in science, but I certainly can't rattle off the average orbital speed of a GPS satellite.
- stcredzero 16y agoYes, but you know full well that current fighter jets can't get very near it. That was one of his obvious mistakes.
- eru 16y agoI could probably work it out in a few minutes on the back of an envelope. You just have to know the radius of earth (around 6000 km), the strength of gravity at surface level, that gravity of a sphere is the same as that of a point mass, and that gravity drops off as the inverse square of distance. Add in some integration, and a guess about how big an orbit is (just choose infinite size for an upper bound, if you aren't sure), and you are set to go.