3 ms·
IMO, apply a flat 1% property tax on the value of a property ignoring zoning restrictions and as long as you pay it feel free. However, understand that tax act
by Retric 7y ago
IMO, apply a flat 1% property tax on the value of a property ignoring zoning restrictions and as long as you pay it feel free. However, understand that tax actually represents paying for physical infrastructure and actual costs people are paying so nobody gets a tax break on it.
Because what’s valuable is not the house but the infrastructure around it. Low density housing requires more infrastructure and higher transportation costs such as longer commutes.
However, I realize everyone loves a hand out, especially when they can pretend it’s not a handout. So, I don’t see this changing any time soon.
- choeger 7y agoBullshit. Infrastructure and transportation have generally always been paid by the owners. There may be cases where residents have successfully lobbied their community to build something for them, but that's not how things work where I live. But even if there was such a support for honeowners, a property tax would be nothing else but theft. Charge the real cost of you want but then leave the people in peace.
- baq 7y agoPlease. Tax is not theft by definition.
- yardie 7y ago> Charge the real cost of you want but then leave the people in peace. And thats the problem. Infrastructure has not been priced correctly. A lot of towns are still paying the bond on initial construction. Leaving very little for maintenance and replacement. And then when the road/sewer/water system needs to be replaced voters don’t have the appetite to pay for it. You see this in older towns in the northeast. Water and sewer mains are corroding. taxes go up to cover it. And the residents flee for newer, cheaper developments. The town eventually becomes insolvent.
- perl4ever 7y agoA distinction I think should be made is that the value of land before you build on it is entirely due to the community and natural characteristics. So why not tax only on that value and not the value of any structure or improvements? The wisest thing I every heard from a libertarian or conservative was "if you tax something you get less of it". It therefore follows, not that we should eliminate taxes, but that we should tax something which is immune to the effect and only that.
- maxsilver 7y ago> Low density housing requires more infrastructure and higher transportation costs such as longer commutes. This does not appear true in the real world. Low density housing requires more mileage of infrastructure, yes, but it's drastically cheaper miles. (You can wire 200 low density suburban houses with electricity across a dozen square miles, for less than the cost to wire up a single building in Manhattan) Density makes infrastructure exponentially more expensive, because the largest costs of infrastructure is in labour and complexity, not the literal length of wire or piping or whatever. > Because what’s valuable is not the house but the infrastructure around it. Low density housing requires more infrastructure and higher transportation costs such as longer commutes. This seems to contradict your own point. If low density housing needed more infrastructure, and houses were valued by the amount of infrastructure they needed, then low density housing would be the most valuable housing. But it's not. In the real world, low density houses are the cheapest housing, and have the cheapest infrastructure costs. High density housing has the highest construction cost, highest land cost, highest infrastructure costs (despite less per-mile infrastructure use), and the highest transportation costs per person (when including total personal+government spending)
- Retric 7y agoThe cost of electrical infrastructure is peanuts in comparison to roads or rail. Yes, the cost of a road in front of a 1,000 apartment skyscraper is more than that if in front of a suburban condo, but not 1,000x as much. Most importantly the commute past time even at walking speed is dramatically less. On top of this the most valuable infrastructure is things like hospitals, restaurants, etc where proximity is a huge deal. NYC has 2,581,170 apartments picture replacing them with single family homes on one acre and the city dies as that’s over 3,900 square miles excluding roads. It’s a classic tragedy of the commons where everyone wants more space, but that does not result in a city.
- maxsilver 7y agoEven that's not really the whole picture. Sure, a road, completely standalone, can cost similarly between a 1k skyscraper and a suburban house. But the road in front of a 1k skyscraper alone will never be enough to transport those people, unless you bump it's price up (make it wide, tack on a parking garage, etc). To prevent that, you'll need something extra (Subway, LRT, a bus line), and that cost will immediately be way higher per-person than the suburban road ever would be. This is something urbanists / StrongTowns types routinely misunderstand. Roads aren't cheap, but they are almost always the cheapest form of public transportation possible in nearly every situation. (Yes, even in total cost of ownership. Yes, even when including the public funding in their cost. And yes, even when including personal vehicle costs). The minute you put even the lightest form of alternative public transit on that road, the cost spikes exponentially. Even the cost to run just a basic busline, with a driver on a timetable, costs more in one year than the entire construction + maintenance budget of that road will cost over 6+ years. (This is not an argument against alt. public transit. I support alt public transit. We should have more trains, subways, and buses, everywhere. It just isn't cheap -- it would require us to spend way more per rider on transit than we are used to, which is why most places are built with public roads only -- it's the absolute cheapest TCO option in nearly every situation)
- perl4ever 7y agoI'm used to the value of the land vs. the structure being listed separately on a property tax bill. The value that is attributable to the community is the value of the land before building. Obviously that's far higher in the middle of NYC or SF or something. So I'm not sure what you are saying about low density housing. There is/was a political movement to finance everything with a tax on the unimproved value of land. The advantage is that with almost everything you can tax, you get less of it, which is usually bad, and besides leads to avoidance and lower revenue. But unimproved land cannot be "discouraged" by taxes, and owners cannot pass the taxes on - their incentive is then to not leave it vacant, which is a very good thing in a dense city.