3 ms·
I can't find details on this bill, but as a former tax lawyer, I am wondering about these issues: • Are contractors counted as employees? If not, then companie
by gnicholas 7y ago
I can't find details on this bill, but as a former tax lawyer, I am wondering about these issues:
• Are contractors counted as employees? If not, then companies would have an incentive to keep low-paid workers as contractors instead of employees.
• How is stock-based compensation, or other incentive-based compensation, treated? Executives are compensated largely with variable compensation like this in order to align their incentives (at least in the short run) with the company's. I could see SBC being exempted from this calculation, which would render the bill largely meaningless. For example, Steve Jobs took $1 in salary for many years.
• What about stock previously owned by the executives? That is, Mark Zuckerberg owns a ton of FB stock, so any income he receives via capital gains or dividends is not tied to his role as CEO. Presumably these are not counted?
- dweekly 7y agoIt may be worth noting that as of two weeks ago AB5 makes the "just recharacterize your employees as contractors" play much more difficult.
- amluto 7y agoI'm not sure this is relevant. You can bring in an outside company as a contractor, and that company can have employees that effectively work for you but aren't employed by you.
- gnicholas 7y agoDefinitely true. As other commenters have noted, you can just outsource the function to another company. That is, I don't think AB5 has any impact on a worker who is an employee of a janitorial firm that is contracted to a tech company. I think it only applies to workers who are directly contracted with/employed by the main company itself. The law would be agnostic about this because the worker is getting the benefits of employment so long as he/she is an employee of some company. This new proposed legislation would make it matter which company is designated as the employer, for purposes of ratio calculation. Note: I have not been able to find the text of this bill, nor have I read AB5 (just read news about it).
- cjlars 7y agoNot true at all. You simply bring in the workers through an employment agency. AB5 does not impact consultants.